Memory problems and a man who still drives
PLAB 2 practice station

Ethics, consent & capacity · 1 min to read · 8 min to perform

Try a real conversation · PLAB 2AI practice

Mr Ronald Ashby, aged 79, was diagnosed with mild Alzheimer’s disease by the memory clinic two months ago.

Ronald AshbyMorning, doctor. Pat’s been fussing again. I’m perfectly all right. I just get a bit muddled with names.

Free · no sign-up · uses your one free station

The task

You are a GP. Mr Ronald Ashby, aged 79, was diagnosed with mild Alzheimer’s disease by the memory clinic two months ago. The letter is in his record. Last week his wife telephoned to say he got lost driving home from the allotment and was missing for two hours. He has come in for a routine review, alone. His record does not show that the DVLA has been told. Talk with him about driving and agree a plan. The examiner will not take part in the conversation.

Answer for this station

What a strong answer does

  • Introduces self, confirms identity, builds rapport and invites Mr Ashby’s own view of how he is coping.
  • Explores his understanding of the diagnosis and his insight, respectfully.
  • Explores driving specifically: frequency, route, getting lost, near misses, scrapes, and who else is affected.
  • Establishes whether he has told the DVLA or his insurer.
  • Safety: Explains clearly that by law he must tell the DVLA about a dementia diagnosis, that this does not automatically mean losing his licence, and that his insurance may be invalid if they are not told.
  • Safety: Advises him to stop driving now, in light of getting lost and the scrapes, until the DVLA has assessed his fitness, as safety for himself and others comes first.
  • Explores alternatives and keeps his independence: friends, community transport, taxis, bus pass, wife as companion, and future reassessment.
  • Explains confidentiality honestly: if he carries on driving when he may not be fit and cannot be persuaded to stop, GMC guidance says the doctor should tell the DVLA medical adviser in confidence if others are at risk, trying to tell him first. Checks he can understand the advice.
  • Responds to his fear of losing independence and being a burden with empathy, and avoids being paternalistic.
  • Documents the discussion and the advice given, and arranges follow-up and support for him and his wife.

Model answer

I give my name and GMC number, introduce myself and confirm Mr Ashby’s identity. I ask how he has been coping since the memory clinic and listen to his account without argument. I explore what he understands about the diagnosis, then ask specifically about driving: how often he drives, the recent episode of getting lost for two hours, the scrapes to the car, and how important driving is to him. He admits he has not told the DVLA or his insurer. I explain kindly and clearly that he is legally required to tell the DVLA about a dementia diagnosis, that this does not automatically end his licence because many people with early dementia can continue driving for a time after an assessment, that he can be fined up to £1,000 if he does not tell them, and that his insurance may be invalid. Given the recent episode and scrapes, I advise him not to drive until the DVLA has assessed his fitness. I acknowledge how much driving means to his independence and ask about alternatives, such as lifts from his friend Derek, community transport and taxis. I explain honestly that if he continues to drive when he may not be fit and refuses to stop, I may be obliged to tell the DVLA medical adviser in confidence, but I would try to tell him first and strongly prefer that he does it. Because his insight is limited, I check that he can understand and remember this advice; if he could not, I should inform the DVLA as soon as practicable. I explain that he can report online or on form CG1, that the DVLA usually decides from medical reports and may ask for a driving assessment, and I offer to help with the form, offer support for him and his wife, and plan follow-up. I record the advice, his response and the plan.

What this station tests

  • A person with dementia must notify the DVLA; it does not automatically end driving, but safety comes first.
  • Advise stopping driving while fitness is assessed if there are recent safety concerns.
  • Be honest about the limits of confidentiality: try to tell the patient first if you will inform the DVLA, and inform it as soon as practicable if dementia stops them understanding your advice.
  • Explore alternatives to preserve independence and address the emotional loss.
  • Document the advice, his understanding and the plan.

Sources for the clinical content

An original practice scenario with invented patients. Not an exam question. Written from the guidance above and reviewed before release: how we write and check stations.

Practise next

About the PLAB 2 →