A lorry driver asking for a fitness letter
PLAB 2 practice station

Ethics, consent & capacity · 1 min to read · 8 min to perform

Try a real conversation · PLAB 2AI practice

Discuss the situation.

Michael TolliverDoctor, I'm fine now. I just need a letter saying I'm fit to drive. I've got a mortgage and loads to deliver. I've got a delivery to Leeds tomorrow.

Free · no sign-up · uses your one free station

The task

You are a GP. Mr Michael Tolliver, aged 46, had a witnessed collapse with shaking at home ten days ago. The hospital discharged him and a neurology appointment is pending. His discharge letter says he should not drive. Today he tells the receptionist he wants a work letter saying he can return to driving his heavy goods vehicle. He is alone. Discuss the situation. The examiner will not take part in the conversation.

Answer for this station

What a strong answer does

  • Introduces self, confirms identity, explores the episode and sets a calm, non-confrontational tone.
  • Takes a focused history of the event, triggers and past history, recognising a probable first seizure that needs specialist assessment.
  • Asks directly whether he has driven since the seizure and whether the DVLA and his insurer know.
  • Safety: Explains clearly that he must not drive any vehicle, including tomorrow's delivery, and that he has a legal duty to tell the DVLA, with stricter rules for heavy goods vehicle licences than for car licences.
  • Explains the risks to him and others on the road, in plain language, without lecturing.
  • Safety: Declines to write a letter saying he is fit to drive, explaining why.
  • Encourages him to tell the DVLA himself and offers support, and says the GMC requires disclosure if he refuses and there is risk, after he has been told.
  • Addresses practical and financial concerns: employer, insurance, benefits advice and alternative work, and suggests a plan with his wife.
  • Arranges follow-up: urgent neurology review, tests, advice on seizure safety, and a clear safety-net about further seizures.
  • Documents the discussion, including advice given, his understanding and the plan for disclosure.

Model answer

I introduce myself, confirm Mr Tolliver's name and date of birth, and take a non-confrontational approach. I ask what happened ten days ago: a witnessed generalised seizure with a period of confusion and incontinence, his first, after poor sleep and alcohol. I ask about head injury, illness, medicines and family history. I ask directly whether he has driven since, and learn that he has driven his car and a lorry, and has not told the DVLA or his insurer. I explain that this is probably a first seizure that needs specialist assessment, and that he must not drive. I explain that he has a legal duty to inform the DVLA, and that rules for heavy goods vehicle licence holders are much stricter than for car drivers, so he may be off the road for a long time. I describe the danger to himself and others without lecturing and acknowledge the financial pressure. I decline to write a letter saying he is fit, and I explain why. I encourage him to tell the DVLA himself and offer help with the form. I explain that GMC guidance requires me to disclose to the DVLA medical adviser if he does not, because of the risk to the public, and that I would tell him before doing so. I discuss his employer, insurance, benefits advice and alternatives such as non-driving work, and offer to involve his wife. I arrange follow-up with neurology, give seizure safety advice and tell him to call 999 for a further seizure. I document the discussion and the plan.

What this station tests

  • Ask directly about driving after a seizure; group 2 (lorry) licence rules are stricter than for car licences.
  • The driver is legally responsible for informing the DVLA; the doctor advises and supports.
  • GMC guidance allows disclosure to the DVLA medical adviser without consent when a patient will not stop driving and the risk is serious, after telling the patient.
  • Do not write a fitness-to-drive letter you cannot support.
  • Acknowledge financial and family consequences and support practical solutions.
  • Poor sleep and alcohol do not make a seizure safe for driving; the DVLA decides, not the patient or GP.

Sources for the clinical content

An original practice scenario with invented patients. Not an exam question. Written from the guidance above and reviewed before release: how we write and check stations.

Practise next

About the PLAB 2 →