The ward manager asks you to speak to a patient
PLAB 2 practice station
Ethics, consent & capacity · 1 min to read · 8 min to perform
Mrs Colette Abernethy, aged 71, had a hip replacement two days ago.
Free · no sign-up · uses your one free station
Open the full station (charts, voice, result letter) →The task
You are a doctor on an orthopaedic ward. Mrs Colette Abernethy, aged 71, had a hip replacement two days ago. This morning a nurse found that a second dose of her blood-thinning injection was given about four hours after the first, because it was charted twice. She does not know. She has no bleeding and her observations are stable. The ward manager has asked you to speak to her. Tell her what has happened. The examiner will not take part in the conversation.
Studying with someone? Practise this station with a friend, free →
Answer for this station
What a strong answer does
- Introduces self, confirms identity, and arranges a private setting and time to talk.
- Safety: Gives a clear warning shot and discloses the error promptly and honestly, without euphemism.
- Apologises sincerely and personally on behalf of the team, in line with the duty of candour, without defensiveness.
- Explains in plain words what happened, what is known and unknown, and the potential harm: extra bleeding risk, most likely to cause bruising.
- Describes the clinical checks and the plan: observations, wound checks, blood tests, senior review and adjusting the next doses.
- Asks what she has noticed and how she feels, and tells her what to report, such as pain, swelling, black stools or faintness.
- Responds to her emotions and worries about discharge, living alone and blaming staff, in a supportive way.
- Explains that the incident has been reported and reviewed, and what will be done to prevent recurrence; offers further explanation or a written account.
- Does not blame colleagues or speculate, stays factual, and offers a named contact for questions.
- Documents the conversation, the apology and the plan, and checks her understanding.
Model answer
I introduce myself, confirm Mrs Abernethy's identity and arrange privacy. I begin with a warning shot and then disclose the error clearly: her blood-thinning injection was charted twice and two doses were given about four hours apart. I apologise sincerely and do not use jargon or minimise. I explain what is known: the second dose was given in error, she has had no bleeding, her observations are stable with a NEWS2 of zero, her wound dressing is dry, and her haemoglobin, platelets and kidney function are reassuring. I explain that the extra dose raises the risk of bleeding, particularly around the new hip, and that this is why we will monitor her closely. I outline the plan: more frequent observations and wound checks, repeat blood tests, review by a senior doctor and adjustment of her next doses, and I explain which symptoms she should report immediately, such as sudden hip pain, swelling, black stools or feeling faint. I respond to her shock and fear about discharge and living alone, and I do not blame any individual. I say that an incident report has been made, the error will be investigated to prevent a repeat, and I offer an account in writing. I do not speculate about the cause. I give her a named contact and check her understanding and questions. In line with the professional duty of candour, I document the disclosure, apology and plan, and I make sure the ward manager and my senior know the outcome.
What this station tests
- Professional duty of candour: tell the patient promptly, apologise and explain what happens next.
- Give facts and avoid speculation or blaming colleagues.
- Explain possible harm and clinical monitoring plans, and what symptoms to report.
- Report the incident through local systems and document the conversation.
- Acknowledge emotions and offer ongoing contact and written feedback.
Sources for the clinical content
- GMC: Candour: openness and honesty when things go wrong
- CQC: Regulation 20: Duty of candour
- NICE NG89: Venous thromboembolism in over 16s
An original practice scenario with invented patients. Not an exam question. Written from the guidance above and reviewed before release: how we write and check stations.