Vomiting blood and declining a transfusion
PLAB 2 practice station
Ethics, consent & capacity · 1 min to read · 8 min to perform
Discuss the options with him and decide how to proceed.
Free · no sign-up · uses your one free station
Open the full station (charts, voice, result letter) →The task
You are a doctor in the emergency department. Mr Emmanuel Agyeman, aged 52, vomited a large amount of blood at home this morning. Endoscopy is arranged for later today. His blood tests show his haemoglobin is low. The team proposes a blood transfusion. He has said he will not accept it. He is alert and has no relatives with him. Discuss the options with him and decide how to proceed. The examiner will not take part in the conversation.
Studying with someone? Practise this station with a friend, free →
Answer for this station
What a strong answer does
- Introduces self, checks identity and builds rapport, speaking with respect for his beliefs and without judgement.
- Assesses the clinical situation quickly: bleeding history, haemodynamic state, haemoglobin and need for urgent senior help and endoscopy.
- Explores which treatments he accepts and refuses, including components, fractions, cell salvage and clotting products, rather than assuming.
- Safety: Explains the risks of refusing blood honestly, including that he could die, and benefits and alternatives.
- Assesses capacity: understanding, retaining, weighing up and communicating, in line with the Mental Capacity Act 2005, and presumes capacity.
- Checks for coercion and that the decision is voluntary, asking about family or elders in the room.
- Asks about a written advance decision, checks it is valid for refusing life-sustaining treatment (in writing, signed, witnessed, and stating it applies even if his life is at risk), explains it would apply if he lost capacity, and documents it.
- Safety: Respects the capacitous refusal, does not give blood against his wishes, and plans the best non-blood management: stopping diclofenac, urgent endoscopy, intravenous iron and senior, haematology and critical care input.
- Involves the right people: senior doctor, hospital liaison committee if he wishes, and keeps his wife informed only with his consent.
- Documents the discussion clearly, reviews capacity if his condition changes, and checks his understanding and any further questions.
Model answer
I introduce myself, confirm Mr Agyeman's name and date of birth and show respect for his faith. I quickly assess his condition: he has had a haematemesis and melaena, he takes diclofenac, his pulse is 108 beats a minute, his blood pressure is 112 over 68 and his haemoglobin is 78 g/L. I arrange urgent senior review and endoscopy. I explore which treatments he accepts. He refuses whole blood, red cells, white cells, platelets and plasma, and I ask separately about fractions, clotting medicines, iron, fluids and cell salvage. I explain honestly the risks of refusing blood: if the bleeding continues he could die. I assess capacity under the Mental Capacity Act 2005 by presuming capacity and testing his ability to understand, retain, weigh and communicate; he does so clearly. I check he is not under pressure from family or elders. He has a signed card in his wallet. I look at the document with him and establish that it is signed, witnessed and states that it applies even if his life is at risk. I explain that while he has capacity his own decision now is what counts, and that the advance decision would guide us if he later lost capacity, for example under sedation. A capacitous adult may refuse treatment even if that may lead to death. I respect his decision, and I do not give blood against his wishes. I plan the best management without blood: stop diclofenac, give intravenous fluids, consider intravenous iron after senior and haematology advice, proceed to early endoscopy, and consider a critical care review. I do not give tranexamic acid, because it is not recommended for upper gastrointestinal bleeding. I ask whether he wants the hospital liaison committee involved and whether his wife should be called. I document the discussion, his capacity and the document, and I review his wishes if his condition or capacity changes.
What this station tests
- A capacitous adult may refuse treatment, including life-saving treatment, for religious or other reasons.
- Explore exactly which blood components and alternatives he accepts; beliefs vary between individuals.
- Test capacity decision-specifically using the Mental Capacity Act 2005 and presume capacity.
- An advance refusal of life-sustaining treatment must be in writing, signed, witnessed and say it applies even if life is at risk. It only applies once the person lacks capacity.
- Offer every acceptable alternative and document carefully.
- Tranexamic acid is not recommended for upper gastrointestinal bleeding; focus on early endoscopy and stopping NSAIDs.
Sources for the clinical content
- Mental Capacity Act 2005
- GMC: Decision making and consent
- NICE NG24: Blood transfusion
- NICE CG141: Acute upper gastrointestinal bleeding in over 16s
An original practice scenario with invented patients. Not an exam question. Written from the guidance above and reviewed before release: how we write and check stations.