A colleague's entry in the notes does not add up
PLAB 2 practice station

Ethics, consent & capacity · 1 min to read · 8 min to perform

Try a real conversation · PLAB 2AI practice

This morning a nurse told you that Mr Frank Patterson in bed 8, four days after a bowel operation, was not seen overnight by the on-call doctor, Dr Hannah Lewis, even…

Hannah LewisOh, hi. You look serious. Is something wrong? I handed everything over at eight.

Free · no sign-up · uses your one free station

The task

You are a foundation doctor on a surgical ward. This morning a nurse told you that Mr Frank Patterson in bed 8, four days after a bowel operation, was not seen overnight by the on-call doctor, Dr Hannah Lewis, even though her note in his record says she examined him and found nothing concerning. His early warning score overnight was 3 and his heart rate was 112 beats/min. You have just reviewed him and arranged tests. Dr Lewis, also a foundation doctor, is now in the doctors' mess. Speak to her about what you have found and decide what must happen next. The examiner will not take part in the conversation.

Answer for this station

What a strong answer does

  • Introduces self, finds a private place and speaks to Dr Lewis respectfully, without ambush or accusation.
  • States the specific concern factually: the note says he was examined but the nurse says he wasn’t seen, and listens to her account.
  • Establishes the facts of the night, workload, support and whether this was an isolated lapse, without colluding or judging prematurely.
  • Safety: Prioritises the patient: confirms that Mr Patterson has been reviewed, is being investigated and managed, and that senior help has been requested.
  • Safety: Explains that entering a false record is dishonest and that doctors have a duty to raise concerns; refuses to keep it secret.
  • Encourages her to report and correct the note herself, and offers to go with her, while making clear that the matter will be escalated either way.
  • Responds with empathy to her exhaustion and distress, asks about her wellbeing and support, and does not minimise.
  • Explains the next steps: informing the registrar and clinical or educational supervisor, correcting the record with a dated addendum, an incident report, and openness with the patient if harm occurred (duty of candour).
  • Does not promise confidentiality or an outcome, such as that she won’t be referred to the GMC.
  • Documents their own review and the conversation factually, and suggests she seeks support from her supervisor, occupational health or the BMA/medical defence organisation.

Model answer

I give my name and GMC number to the examiner, then ask Dr Lewis if we can talk privately. I state my concern factually: the record says she examined Mr Patterson but the nurse says she did not. I listen. She admits she was overwhelmed during a very busy night, wrote that she had reviewed him, meant to go back and did not. I ask what happened that night, whether she had help and whether this has happened before. I tell her that Mr Patterson is my first priority: I have reviewed him, arranged tests and informed my registrar. I explain calmly that an inaccurate record is a serious matter, that we have a duty to be honest and to raise concerns, and that I cannot keep it secret, whatever she asks. I encourage her to tell the registrar herself and offer to go with her, but I make it clear that I will raise it if she does not. I respond with empathy to her exhaustion and distress and ask about her wellbeing, sleep and support. I explain the process: tell the registrar and clinical supervisor, add a clear dated correction to the record, complete an incident report, and share what happened with Mr Patterson if he has been harmed. I do not promise she will avoid referral. I suggest she speak to her supervisor, occupational health and her defence organisation. I document my own review and the conversation, and ask the registrar to consider whether she is fit to work tonight and to arrange support.

What this station tests

  • Patient safety comes first: check and treat the patient before dealing with the colleague.
  • A false record is dishonesty; doctors must be honest and cannot agree to keep such matters secret.
  • Give the colleague the chance to report themselves, but escalate regardless.
  • Be kind: exhaustion and fear are common; ask about wellbeing and signpost support.
  • Do not promise outcomes you cannot control.

Sources for the clinical content

An original practice scenario with invented patients. Not an exam question. Written from the guidance above and reviewed before release: how we write and check stations.

Practise next

About the PLAB 2 →