Talking about resuscitation with a frail older woman
PLAB 2 practice station
Ethics, consent & capacity · 1 min to read · 8 min to perform
Mrs Winifred Pascoe, aged 86, has advanced heart failure, kidney disease and frailty, and this is her third admission this year.
Free · no sign-up · uses your one free station
Open the full station (charts, voice, result letter) →The task
You are a foundation doctor on an elderly care ward, with your registrar’s agreement. Mrs Winifred Pascoe, aged 86, has advanced heart failure, kidney disease and frailty, and this is her third admission this year. She is improving after a chest infection. She has capacity. The team feel that CPR is unlikely to work if her heart stopped, and a decision has not yet been discussed with her. Her daughter lives abroad. Talk with Mrs Pascoe about her wishes for the future and agree a plan. The examiner will not take part in the conversation.
Studying with someone? Practise this station with a friend, free →
Answer for this station
What a strong answer does
- Introduces self, finds privacy, gets her hearing aid or sits close, and asks permission to talk about future care.
- Explores her understanding of her illnesses, her experiences and what matters most to her before discussing resuscitation.
- Safety: Corrects the misconception about CPR gently and honestly: it often fails in people with advanced heart failure, frailty and multiple illnesses, and can cause injury; avoids false figures.
- Makes a clear recommendation rather than asking her to decide alone, while respecting her views: that attempting CPR would be unlikely to work and would not benefit her, and records her agreement.
- Safety: Explains that a decision not to attempt CPR does not mean withdrawal of care: she will still receive antibiotics, fluids, comfort and the treatments she wants.
- Responds to her fears (sister’s death, abandonment, burden) with empathy.
- Explores whether she wants anyone else involved, such as her daughter, and what she wishes to be told and when.
- Describes how the decision will be recorded (recommended summary plan such as a ReSPECT form), given to her, shared with her GP and ambulance services, and can be reviewed at any time.
- Discusses what she would want if she became very unwell: whether hospital, where she’d want to be cared for, and preferences for future care.
- Checks understanding, invites questions, documents the discussion, and informs the team.
Model answer
I give my name and GMC number and introduce myself. I check that Mrs Pascoe can hear me, offer privacy and ask whether she is willing to talk about the future. I start by asking what she understands about her heart and kidneys, her recent admissions and what matters most to her. She tells me about her sister’s long ventilation, her wish to stay at home with her cat and her fear of being kept alive on machines. I ask what she knows about resuscitation and gently correct her belief that it nearly always works. I explain honestly that for someone with advanced heart failure, kidney disease and frailty, it is unlikely to restart her heart and could cause pain and injury, without quoting made-up numbers. I give a clear recommendation, as she is entitled to a doctor’s view: that attempting CPR would be unlikely to work and would not benefit her. I check that it fits her own wishes. When she fears being abandoned, I explain that a decision about CPR does not mean she will stop being treated: she will still receive antibiotics, diuretics and comfort care. I ask whether she wants her daughter involved and when. I explain how the decision will be recorded in a summary plan such as a ReSPECT form, that she keeps a copy, that her GP and ambulance service will see it, and that it can be reviewed at any time. It is a recommendation, not legally binding; if she wants a binding refusal I explain that an advance decision is the way to do that. I discuss what she would want if she became very unwell, check her understanding, invite questions and document the conversation and tell the team.
What this station tests
- Start with what the patient understands and values, not with the form.
- Be honest about CPR success in frailty and multiple illnesses; correct television myths gently.
- Doctors should recommend; do not leave a frightened patient to decide alone.
- Make clear that a CPR decision is not a decision to stop other treatment.
- Record the decision in a summary plan, share it and say it can be reviewed.
Sources for the clinical content
- Resuscitation Council UK: ReSPECT
- GMC: Treatment and care towards the end of life
- GMC: Decision making and consent
- Resuscitation Council UK: Decisions relating to cardiopulmonary resuscitation
An original practice scenario with invented patients. Not an exam question. Written from the guidance above and reviewed before release: how we write and check stations.