Police officer asks about a patient at the surgery
PLAB 2 practice station

Ethics, consent & capacity · 1 min to read · 8 min to perform

Try a real conversation · PLAB 2AI practice

A police officer, PC Dean Hollis, has come to the surgery without an appointment.

Dean HollisMorning, doctor. PC Hollis, Northgate station. I need a quick word. I’m investigating a serious assault and I think one of your patients may have turned up here yesterday with a hand injury.

Free · no sign-up · uses your one free station

The task

You are a GP. A police officer, PC Dean Hollis, has come to the surgery without an appointment. He says he is investigating a serious assault and asks whether a patient of the practice, Mr Jordan Pryce, aged 27, attended yesterday with an injury. Mr Pryce is not in the building and you have not asked him. You have his record open. The practice has no Caldicott Guardian available at the moment, but the practice manager is in the building. Speak to the officer and decide what to do. The examiner will not take part in the conversation.

Answer for this station

What a strong answer does

  • Introduces self, asks for the officer’s identification and checks it, and sees him in private.
  • Safety: Does not confirm or deny that Mr Pryce is a patient or attended, and explains that patient information is confidential and cannot be given on request.
  • Asks what offence is being investigated, how serious it is and why the information is needed, and what is the minimum required.
  • Explains the legal and ethical framework: disclosure without consent is justified only if required by law or if the public interest in preventing or prosecuting serious crime outweighs the patient’s confidentiality, and must be proportionate and limited to what is needed.
  • Asks for the request in writing on the police form, authorised by a senior officer, stating the purpose and information sought.
  • Seeks advice before any disclosure: from the practice manager, Caldicott Guardian or data protection lead, or a medical defence organisation, and records the advice.
  • Considers whether it would be appropriate to ask Mr Pryce for consent, and recognises the risk that tipping him off might prejudice the investigation.
  • States that if disclosure is justified, only the minimum relevant information will be shared and the decision and reasons will be documented, and that the patient should usually be told unless that would put others at risk or undermine the investigation.
  • Remains courteous and firm under pressure, acknowledges the seriousness of the assault, and explains what will happen next and when.
  • Safety: Does not hand over, read out or show notes while talking to the officer.

Model answer

I give my name and GMC number, ask to see PC Hollis’s warrant card and invite him into a private room. I treat his request seriously but do not confirm or deny that Mr Pryce is a patient or attended. I explain that patient information is confidential and that I cannot share it simply because I am asked. I ask what offence is being investigated, how serious it is, why the information is needed and what the minimum is. He tells me a man is in intensive care after an assault. I explain the framework: disclosure without consent is justified if required by law, such as a court order, or if the public interest in preventing or prosecuting a serious crime outweighs the patient’s confidentiality, and then only the minimum relevant information, never the full notes. I ask for the request in writing, authorised by a senior officer and stating the purpose. I explain that I will take advice from the practice manager and data protection lead, and I can call my medical defence organisation. I consider whether Mr Pryce should be asked for consent, and whether doing so would prejudice the investigation. If I decide disclosure is justified, I will share only what is necessary, document my reasoning, and tell Mr Pryce unless that would put others at risk or undermine the investigation. I stay courteous and calm under pressure, acknowledge the seriousness, tell him when he will have an answer and do not disclose or show the record in the meantime. I document the encounter.

What this station tests

  • Do not confirm or deny that someone is a patient when asked informally.
  • Disclosure without consent needs a legal requirement or a clear public interest in serious crime, and must be the minimum needed.
  • Ask for a written request and take advice; document the decision and the reasons.
  • Consider consent, and whether asking or telling the patient would put anyone at risk or prejudice the investigation.
  • Stay polite and clear; refusing to disclose on the spot is not refusing to cooperate.

Sources for the clinical content

An original practice scenario with invented patients. Not an exam question. Written from the guidance above and reviewed before release: how we write and check stations.

Practise next

About the PLAB 2 →