Confused man who wants to go home from the ward
PLAB 2 practice station
Ethics, consent & capacity · 1 min to read · 8 min to perform
Mr Albert Hargreaves, aged 74, was admitted three days ago with pneumonia and is receiving intravenous antibiotics.
Free · no sign-up · uses your one free station
Open the full station (charts, voice, result letter) →The task
You are a foundation doctor on a medical ward. Mr Albert Hargreaves, aged 74, was admitted three days ago with pneumonia and is receiving intravenous antibiotics. The nurse has asked you to come because he has put on his coat and says he is leaving to feed his dog. He has been more confused since last night. Talk to him, assess whether he can make this decision and decide what to do. The examiner will answer questions about observations. The examiner will not take part in the conversation.
Studying with someone? Practise this station with a friend, free →
Answer for this station
What a strong answer does
- Introduces self, stays calm and non-confrontational, talks to him at his level, and stops him leaving unsafely without using force.
- Acknowledges his worry about the dog and checks the practical problem, for example that a neighbour or relative can feed her.
- Safety: Starts from the assumption that he has capacity, and tests the specific decision to leave hospital: whether he understands his illness and treatment, retains the information, weighs the risks and benefits, and communicates a choice.
- Checks for causes of acute confusion: pain, infection, retention, constipation, dehydration, medicines; asks about passing water and bowels.
- Requests and interprets the observations, recognising a NEWS2 of 4 with new confusion, and the palpable bladder as a likely contributor to delirium.
- Safety: Concludes with reasons that on this occasion he lacks capacity because his confusion stops him weighing the information, and documents that the decision is for this time only.
- Acts in his best interests using the least restrictive option: continue treatment, treat reversible causes such as catheterisation for retention, keep him safe on the ward with supervision, and does not restrain him except as a last resort in line with local policy.
- Involves his son or neighbour with his agreement or in his best interests, and informs the senior doctor.
- Provides delirium-friendly care: reorientate, glasses and hearing aids, light, familiar objects, avoiding unnecessary sedatives, monitor and review capacity.
- Documents the assessment, the decision and the reasons clearly.
Model answer
I give my name and GMC number, introduce myself and stay calm. I do not block him physically but ask him to sit with me, and I listen to his worry about his dog. I ask who is looking after Bess so I can address the practical problem. I assume he has capacity unless shown otherwise and assess it for this decision using the Mental Capacity Act: does he understand why he is in hospital and what treatment he is having, can he retain it, can he weigh the risks of leaving, and can he communicate a decision. He thinks he is at home and that he is well, and cannot weigh the information. I ask about pain, passing water, bowels and medicines, as new confusion is likely to be delirium. I ask the examiner for observations and see a NEWS2 of 4, with heart rate 1 and new confusion 3. A palpable bladder with 600 mL on scan is a clear reversible cause. I conclude he lacks capacity for this decision at this time, explain that this may fluctuate and document the reasons. I act in his best interests with the least restrictive approach: continue antibiotics, arrange catheterisation for retention, treat constipation and pain, keep him safe on the ward with supervision and not use force or sedation unless unavoidable and in line with local policy. I ask my senior whether a Deprivation of Liberty authorisation is needed if he must be kept here against his wishes. I involve his son and neighbour, ring Carol about the dog, reorientate him and review capacity, and tell my senior and the nurse in charge. I document everything.
What this station tests
- Presume capacity, but test it for the specific decision at the specific time; capacity can fluctuate.
- New confusion in an unwell patient is delirium until proven otherwise: look for retention, constipation, pain, infection and drugs.
- Best interests means the least restrictive option, with family involved; avoid restraint and sedation where possible.
- Address the practical worry that drives the behaviour, here the dog.
- Record the assessment, the reasons and when it will be reviewed.
Sources for the clinical content
- Mental Capacity Act 2005
- Mental Capacity Act Code of Practice
- NICE CG103: Delirium: prevention, diagnosis and management
- GMC: Decision making and consent
An original practice scenario with invented patients. Not an exam question. Written from the guidance above and reviewed before release: how we write and check stations.