Giving a breast biopsy result in clinic
PLAB 2 practice station
Breaking bad news · 1 min to read · 8 min to perform
Mrs Ngozi Bello, aged 47, attended last week with a lump in her right breast.
Free · no sign-up · uses your one free station
Open the full station (charts, voice, result letter) →The task
You are a doctor in a breast clinic. Mrs Ngozi Bello, aged 47, attended last week with a lump in her right breast. She had an examination, imaging and a core biopsy. The multidisciplinary team has reviewed the results. The biopsy shows an invasive breast cancer of about 2 cm, with no other abnormality seen on imaging so far. She has come alone. A breast care nurse is available after your consultation. Tell Mrs Bello the result and agree the next step. You do not need to examine her. The examiner will not take part in the conversation.
Studying with someone? Practise this station with a friend, free →
Answer for this station
What a strong answer does
- Introduces self, checks identity, ensures privacy and that she is comfortable, and asks whether she wishes someone with her.
- Establishes what she already understands and expects, and asks how much she wishes to be told.
- Safety: Gives a warning shot, then states the diagnosis clearly in plain words: the biopsy shows a cancer in the breast, without euphemism or jargon.
- Pauses, allows silence, acknowledges and responds to emotion, and does not rush on to treatment.
- Safety: Gives honest, limited information about extent and outlook: it is about 2 cm, scans so far show nothing else, more tests are needed to know more, and many breast cancers are treatable. Does not give survival figures or false reassurance.
- Responds to her fear about her sister and her children with empathy rather than reassurance she cannot verify.
- Explains the next steps simply: team plan, further tests, treatment discussion at a follow-up visit, with surgery often the first option, without asking her to decide today.
- Introduces the breast care nurse as a named contact, offers written information and checks her support, including telling her husband and offering to meet them together.
- Checks understanding, invites questions and arranges a follow-up appointment with a clear route to ask more.
- Documents the conversation and plan, and ensures the GP is informed.
Model answer
I give my name and GMC number, introduce myself, confirm Mrs Bello’s identity and ask whether she would like anyone with her. I check what she already understands and how much she wants to hear. She says she expects bad news and wants honesty, so I give a short warning shot: I am afraid the news is not good. I then state the diagnosis in plain words, without euphemism: the biopsy shows that the lump is a cancer. I stop and let her take it in. I allow silence, acknowledge her shock and respond to her feelings before I say anything more. When she asks whether she will die like her sister, I do not offer false reassurance or statistics. I say honestly that I cannot answer that today, that scans so far show nothing further, that more tests are needed and that many breast cancers are treatable. I acknowledge that her sister’s death makes this especially frightening. I explain next steps in small pieces: the team will agree a plan, treatment is often by operation, there will be a follow-up appointment to discuss options, and nothing has to be decided today. I introduce the breast care nurse as a named contact and arrange for her to speak to Mrs Bello straight away. I say the team will take her sister’s history into account, including whether genetics advice is needed. I ask about support at home and offer to see her with her husband. I give written information, ask her to repeat back what she has understood, invite questions and arrange follow-up. I record the consultation and inform her GP.
What this station tests
- Use a warning shot, then say the word cancer clearly; euphemisms leave patients confused.
- Stop talking after the diagnosis; silence and empathy matter more than information at that moment.
- Do not give prognosis you cannot know; be honest about what is known and what tests will clarify.
- Offer a named nurse, written information and a plan for follow-up, and check support at home.
- Explore ideas, fears and family history before and after the news.
Sources for the clinical content
- NICE NG101: Early and locally advanced breast cancer: diagnosis and management
- GMC: Good medical practice
- NHS: Breast cancer in women
An original practice scenario with invented patients. Not an exam question. Written from the guidance above and reviewed before release: how we write and check stations.