A son arrives on the ward at dawn
PLAB 2 practice station
Breaking bad news · 1 min to read · 8 min to perform
Mrs Phyllis Blackwood, aged 86, was admitted three days ago with pneumonia and frailty.
Free · no sign-up · uses your one free station
Open the full station (charts, voice, result letter) →The task
You are a medical doctor on an acute medical ward. Mrs Phyllis Blackwood, aged 86, was admitted three days ago with pneumonia and frailty. Her condition worsened overnight. The ward rang her son at about four o'clock, when she became worse. She died forty minutes ago, comfortable, with a nurse at her bedside. A decision not to attempt resuscitation was agreed with her on admission. Her son, Ewart, has just arrived and has been shown to the relatives' room. Tell him and respond to his concerns. The examiner will not take part in the conversation.
Studying with someone? Practise this station with a friend, free →
Answer for this station
What a strong answer does
- Introduces self, confirms who he is and his relationship, and checks he is sitting down in a private room.
- Finds out what he already knows and gives a clear warning shot before the news.
- Safety: States clearly and kindly that his mother has died, using the word died or dead rather than euphemisms.
- Allows silence and responds to his emotions, including guilt and anger, with empathy and without defensiveness.
- Gives honest information about her final hours: she deteriorated from the pneumonia, was comfortable and had a nurse with her.
- Explains the resuscitation decision accurately, confirming it was agreed with her and that she was treated according to her wishes.
- Answers questions about timing honestly, acknowledging he was called and offering to explain the timeline without blaming anyone.
- Offers to let him see her and sit with her, with a nurse available, and asks about religious or cultural wishes.
- Explains practical next steps: the medical certificate, the medical examiner's review (their office may phone him), registering the death, belongings and the bereavement office.
- Offers support for him and family, checks he is safe to get home or has someone with him, and invites further questions.
Model answer
I introduce myself in the relatives' room and invite Mr Blackwood to sit. I confirm who he is and ask what he has been told. I give a warning that I have sad news and say clearly that his mother died about forty minutes ago, using the word died and no euphemism. I pause and give him time. He is angry that he arrived too late and guilty; I acknowledge his feelings, avoid defensiveness and do not make excuses. When he asks, I explain honestly that her pneumonia worsened during the night, that she was comfortable and that a nurse was with her. I confirm that, as agreed with her on admission, no attempt at resuscitation was made and that it would not have helped. I acknowledge that we rang him when she deteriorated and that I am sorry he could not be there. I offer to explain more or to review the timeline later. I ask whether he would like to see his mother and sit with her, and I offer a nurse or chaplain and ask about his wishes. I explain the next steps in plain words: I will complete the medical certificate after the medical examiner has reviewed the death, the bereavement office will explain how to register the death and collect her belongings and he can ring the ward at any time. I ask whether someone can be with him and whether he is safe to drive home, and I invite his remaining questions. I thank him, document the conversation and ensure the team knows.
What this station tests
- Prepare the setting, check who the person is and give a warning shot.
- Say 'died' clearly; euphemisms cause confusion and add distress.
- Respond to guilt and anger with empathy, not defensiveness, and be honest about the timeline.
- Explain what happens next in plain words: viewing, certificate, medical examiner and registration.
- Check support and safety, for example the ability to travel home.
Sources for the clinical content
- GMC: Treatment and care towards the end of life
- gov.uk: What to do after someone dies
- NHS: Bereavement
An original practice scenario with invented patients. Not an exam question. Written from the guidance above and reviewed before release: how we write and check stations.