Scan results two years after bowel surgery
PLAB 2 practice station

Breaking bad news · 1 min to read · 8 min to perform

Try a real conversation · PLAB 2AI practice

Explain the result and respond to her concerns.

Rukhsana BegumHello doctor. I came on my own because my husband had to take the car to the garage. The letter said my scan showed some changes. Is it back?

Free · no sign-up · uses your one free station

The task

You are a doctor in an oncology outpatient clinic. Mrs Rukhsana Begum, aged 58, had surgery two years ago for bowel cancer. Recent scans show that it has spread to her liver and lungs. The team plans treatment to control the disease, but a cure is not possible. She has been told only that her scan 'showed some changes'. She is alone. Explain the result and respond to her concerns. The examiner will not take part in the conversation.

Answer for this station

What a strong answer does

  • Introduces self, confirms identity, ensures privacy and offers a support person to be present.
  • Explores her understanding and how much she wants to know before sharing results.
  • Gives a clear warning shot, then states plainly that the cancer has come back and spread to her liver and lungs.
  • Safety: Is honest that the cancer cannot be cured, while explaining that treatment aims to control it, extend life and improve symptoms.
  • Allows silence, acknowledges her emotions and responds with empathy.
  • Answers the question about time honestly without false precision, saying it is hard to predict and may be months to years, and that the team will review how she responds.
  • Explores concerns about family and wishes, acknowledging the wedding goal and what matters to her.
  • Explains next steps: discussion by the cancer team, chemotherapy options, specialist nurse contact, symptom support and palliative care involvement alongside treatment.
  • Offers support for her and her family, checks understanding, gives written information and arranges follow-up.

Model answer

I introduce myself, confirm Mrs Begum's identity and offer her husband's involvement. I ask what she understands and how much she wants to know; she wants the truth with few numbers at first. I give a warning shot and say plainly that the cancer has returned and spread to her liver and lungs. I stop and allow silence, acknowledge that she feared this, and give her time. When she asks whether it can be cured, I answer honestly that it cannot, while explaining that treatment can control the disease, extend life and ease symptoms. When she asks how long she has, I explain that I cannot be exact, that people vary widely and that it is often months to years, and that the team will learn more as treatment is given. I avoid false reassurance and avoid giving rigid numbers. I explore what matters to her, including her daughter's wedding in April, and explore her fears about pain and about her family. I explain the next steps: her case will be discussed by the cancer team, and chemotherapy options will be reviewed with her and her husband. A clinical nurse specialist will be her point of contact, and palliative care will help with symptoms alongside treatment. I offer to write things down and to book a follow-up with her husband present, check what she has understood, and ask whether she wants to ask more. I give contact numbers, ensure she has support to get home safely, and document the conversation.

What this station tests

  • Check what the patient understands and wants to know before sharing.
  • State the news plainly with a warning shot, then stop and give silence.
  • Be honest that cure is not possible while explaining what treatment can achieve.
  • Avoid false precision on prognosis: describe uncertainty honestly.
  • Link goals to what matters to the patient and arrange named support.

Sources for the clinical content

An original practice scenario with invented patients. Not an exam question. Written from the guidance above and reviewed before release: how we write and check stations.

Practise next

About the PLAB 2 →