Memory clinic results with a worried daughter
PLAB 2 practice station
Breaking bad news · 1 min to read · 8 min to perform
Mr Bhupinder Sohal, aged 78, was referred by his GP after two years of worsening forgetfulness.
Free · no sign-up · uses your one free station
Open the full station (charts, voice, result letter) →The task
You are a doctor in a memory clinic. Mr Bhupinder Sohal, aged 78, was referred by his GP after two years of worsening forgetfulness. Cognitive testing, blood tests and a brain scan are complete and together support Alzheimer's disease. He has come with his daughter, Navdeep. Before the appointment she asked that he is not told the word 'dementia'. Share the diagnosis and respond to both of them. The examiner will not take part in the conversation.
Studying with someone? Practise this station with a friend, free →
Answer for this station
What a strong answer does
- Introduces self, confirms the patient's identity and checks who is present and whether he is happy for his daughter to stay.
- Addresses the patient directly, finds out what he understands and how much he wants to know before sharing news.
- Safety: Acknowledges the daughter's request with respect but does not agree to hide the diagnosis from Mr Sohal, who has capacity and wants to know; explains he has the right to his results.
- Gives a clear warning, then states the diagnosis in plain words without euphemism: Alzheimer's disease, a type of dementia.
- Pauses, acknowledges emotion, and responds with empathy and silence.
- Explains honestly that it is progressive and cannot be cured, but that treatment and support can help, and that it varies between people.
- Discusses support and next steps: memory service follow-up, nurse specialist, medicines that may help symptoms, Alzheimer's Society and carer support.
- Raises safety and legal planning: he must tell the DVLA and should not drive until it is assessed, home safety such as the gas, a lasting power of attorney while he can still make one, and his wishes for the future.
- Offers support for the daughter, including a carer's assessment and where to find help.
- Checks understanding, invites questions, offers written information and arranges follow-up.
Model answer
I introduce myself, confirm Mr Sohal's name and date of birth, and check that he is happy for his daughter to stay. Before sharing the result I ask Mr Sohal what he has noticed and how much he wants to know. He tells me he wants the full truth. I then acknowledge Navdeep's request, explaining kindly that her father has the right to know and has asked to be told, and I invite her concerns; her mother's experience explains her protectiveness. I give a warning shot and then say clearly: the tests and scan show Alzheimer's disease, which is a form of dementia. I stop and allow silence, and respond to his sadness and relief. I explain in plain words that this is a progressive condition that cannot be cured, that people are affected differently and that there is treatment and support. I avoid prognosis figures but answer honestly when he asks about the future. I explain next steps: continued follow-up in the memory service, a named nurse, medicines that can help symptoms for some people, and the Alzheimer's Society. I discuss safety, including his legal duty to tell the DVLA about his diagnosis and my advice not to drive until that is assessed, given that he recently got lost, medicines support, and gas safety. I raise lasting power of attorney and ask about his wishes for the future. I offer Navdeep a carer's assessment and support for herself. I check understanding, give written information that he can share with his son, arrange follow-up with his daughter present and document the consultation.
What this station tests
- Check what the patient wants to know first; he has the right to be told and to decide who hears it.
- Respectfully explore a relative's request to withhold information, but do not collude with concealment from a capacitous patient.
- Name the diagnosis clearly and use silence and empathy.
- Be honest that dementia is progressive without removing hope: support exists.
- Cover driving (DVLA), power of attorney, carers and follow-up.
Sources for the clinical content
- NICE NG97: Dementia: assessment, management and support
- Alzheimer's Society: Getting a diagnosis
- gov.uk: Driving and dementia
An original practice scenario with invented patients. Not an exam question. Written from the guidance above and reviewed before release: how we write and check stations.