Angry daughter after her mother fell on the ward
PLAB 2 practice station

Ethics, consent & capacity · 1 min to read · 8 min to perform

Try a real conversation · PLAB 2AI practice

Mrs Dolores Doherty, aged 84, fell at about 3 am on her way to the toilet and was found by a healthcare assistant.

Maeve DohertyNobody even rang me until eight o'clock! My mother is lying there with a broken wrist and I want to know how this was allowed to happen.

Free · no sign-up · uses your one free station

The task

You are a foundation doctor on an elderly care ward. Mrs Dolores Doherty, aged 84, fell at about 3 am on her way to the toilet and was found by a healthcare assistant. A wrist fracture has been seen on X-ray and she has been given pain relief. An incident form has been completed and her daughter was telephoned at 8 am. The daughter has arrived on the ward, is upset and has asked to see a doctor. Your consultant is in clinic. Speak to the daughter, respond to her concerns and agree what happens next. The examiner will not take part in the conversation.

Answer for this station

What a strong answer does

  • Introduces self, confirms who she is and her relationship to Mrs Doherty, finds a private space, and lets her express anger without interrupting.
  • Acknowledges her anger and fear and gives an early, sincere apology that a fall and injury has happened and for the way she was told.
  • Explains honestly what is known: the time and place of the fall, the wrist fracture, her pain control and current plan, without speculating about causes.
  • Safety: Does not deny, minimise, or blame the patient or staff, and says plainly that it will be investigated, including whether the call bell was answered.
  • Explores her earlier concerns about walking support and the dementia, and takes them seriously.
  • Outlines what will happen for her mother: orthopaedic review, analgesia, post-fall checks including for head injury, falls precautions such as lower bed and supervised toileting, and how she can see her mother now.
  • Offers a meeting with the consultant and ward manager, a named contact and the complaints route through the Patient Advice and Liaison Service.
  • States that the incident is reported and investigated under the trust's patient safety process and that she will be told the findings (duty of candour).
  • Recognises the mother is the patient: checks Mrs Doherty is safe, comfortable and not left distressed, and keeps the daughter involved with consent.
  • Documents the conversation and informs the nurse in charge and the consultant.

Model answer

I give my name and GMC number and introduce myself to Ms Doherty, confirm who she is and ask whether she would like to talk somewhere private. I let her say what she needs to, without interrupting, and reflect back her anger and fear. I apologise at once and sincerely: I am sorry her mother has been hurt and sorry about how she was told. I do not become defensive. I tell her plainly what I know: the time of the fall, that she was found by a healthcare assistant, the wrist fracture seen on X-ray and the pain relief given. I do not speculate. When she asks if the bell was ignored, I say I do not know yet, that it will be looked into properly, and that she will be told the findings. I do not say these things happen, and I do not blame the staff or Mrs Doherty. I ask about her earlier concerns about walking and dementia and take them seriously, saying I will check they are recorded. I explain the plan: orthopaedic review, regular analgesia, post-fall checks including for any head injury, extra support for toileting and a falls review. I offer a meeting with the consultant and ward manager, explain that the incident has been reported and is being investigated and that she will hear the outcome in writing, and describe the Patient Advice and Liaison Service and formal complaints route. I do not promise outcomes I cannot control, such as discharge on Friday. I offer to take her to see her mother, check Mrs Doherty is comfortable, document the discussion and tell the nurse in charge and consultant.

What this station tests

  • Apologise early and sincerely; apologising is not an admission of liability.
  • Be honest about what you do not yet know; do not speculate about blame.
  • Take earlier concerns seriously and say how they will be checked.
  • Explain the incident process, the next step and who will contact the family.
  • Remember the patient: a distressed relative does not replace checking on the person who was hurt.

Sources for the clinical content

An original practice scenario with invented patients. Not an exam question. Written from the guidance above and reviewed before release: how we write and check stations.

Practise next

About the PLAB 2 →