Patient unhappy about a referral that never arrived
PLAB 2 practice station

Ethics, consent & capacity · 1 min to read · 8 min to perform

Try a real conversation · PLAB 2AI practice

Mrs Yvonne Baptiste, aged 61, has asked to speak to a doctor about a complaint.

Yvonne BaptisteI've come to make a complaint. I was told three weeks ago I'd be seen urgently about my mole, and I've heard absolutely nothing.

Free · no sign-up · uses your one free station

The task

You are a GP. Mrs Yvonne Baptiste, aged 61, has asked to speak to a doctor about a complaint. Three weeks ago a colleague examined a changing mole on her back and said an urgent referral to the skin cancer team would be sent. She has heard nothing. Your colleague has since left the practice. The practice manager has just told you the referral letter was never sent. You have the record open. Speak to Mrs Baptiste, deal with her concerns and agree what happens next. You do not need to examine her. The examiner will not take part in the conversation.

Answer for this station

What a strong answer does

  • Introduces self and name, checks Mrs Baptiste's identity, and invites her to explain her concerns without interrupting.
  • Gives a prompt, sincere apology for the delay and for the worry it has caused, without defensiveness.
  • Safety: Tells her openly that the referral was not sent, explains what is known so far and does not blame the colleague who left or the reception team.
  • Safety: Takes responsibility for acting now: sends the referral as a suspected skin cancer pathway referral today, checks it is received, and gives her a named person and a date for contact.
  • Takes a brief history of the mole and checks for red-flag features such as bleeding, change or other symptoms, and asks if she wants the lesion looked at today.
  • Acknowledges her anxiety and sleep loss and explores what worries her most.
  • Explains how to make a formal complaint to the practice and, if unresolved, to the Parliamentary and Health Service Ombudsman, without discouraging her.
  • Describes what will be done to stop it recurring, such as a review of how urgent referrals are tracked, and says she will hear the result.
  • Is honest about not promising a diagnosis or an appointment date, and avoids false reassurance.
  • Records the event, informs the practice manager and plans to report it as a significant event, in line with the professional duty of candour.

Model answer

I give my name and GMC number, introduce myself and check Mrs Baptiste's name and date of birth. I invite her to explain why she is upset and listen without interrupting. She tells me about the delay and her fear. I apologise sincerely and early, saying I am sorry the referral did not go when she was promised and sorry for the worry. I do not use jargon or defensive language. I tell her honestly what I know: the record shows the referral was not sent. I say I do not yet know why, that we will find out and share what we learn, and that I will not blame an individual. I ask about the mole, how it has changed, bleeding and other symptoms, and I offer to look at it today. I acknowledge that her sister's melanoma makes this especially frightening. I then explain what happens next. I will write the suspected skin cancer referral today and mark it urgent, I will phone her tomorrow to confirm receipt, and I tell her when she will hear from me. I do not promise a diagnosis or a date I cannot control, but explain the urgent suspected cancer pathway, where the aim is to find or rule out cancer within 28 days of referral. I explain how to make a formal complaint to the practice manager and, if unresolved, to the Parliamentary and Health Service Ombudsman, and that she will get a written reply. I tell her we will record this as a significant event, review how urgent referrals are tracked and tell her the outcome. I check that she is happy with the plan, answer her questions, give a direct contact route and document the conversation and actions.

What this station tests

  • Apologise promptly and sincerely; an apology is not an admission of legal liability.
  • Fix the clinical problem first: get the urgent referral sent and confirmed.
  • Be open about what is known and not known; do not blame colleagues.
  • Explain the complaints route clearly without discouraging it.
  • Record the incident and learn from it: duty of candour includes telling the patient what will change.

Sources for the clinical content

An original practice scenario with invented patients. Not an exam question. Written from the guidance above and reviewed before release: how we write and check stations.

Practise next

About the PLAB 2 →