An adult patient wants a result kept from family
NAC OSCE practice station

Ethics, consent & capacity · 2 min to read · 11 min to perform

Try a real conversation · NAC OSCEAI practice

Explain confidentiality and its relevant limits, discuss support and referral, and agree a safe follow-up and contact plan.

Gurdeep BrarPlease do not tell my father about this result.

Free · no sign-up · uses your one free station

The task

You are a doctor in an outpatient clinic in Ontario, Canada. Gurdeep Brar, aged 26, is attending to discuss a confirmed HIV result. His father has asked reception for details. Gurdeep is being seen alone and does not consent to family disclosure. Explore his understanding, concerns and safety. Explain confidentiality and its relevant limits, discuss support and referral, and agree a safe follow-up and contact plan.

Answer for this station

What a strong answer does

  • Confirms identity using reliable available sources, explains actions and seeks appropriate consent, preserving privacy without delaying emergency care.
  • Elicits the presenting pattern: Who knows the result and whom, if anyone, do you consent to involve?
  • Checks the patient-specific associated risks: Are you safe at home, and are there partners or others who may need support or public-health advice?
  • For Gurdeep, performs or describes how to assess understanding and communication.
  • Explains the working assessment for Gurdeep without claiming unsupported certainty.
  • Selects appropriate investigations or record review for Gurdeep, without delaying urgent care.
  • Proposes the patient-specific management or shared decision plan for Gurdeep.
  • Safety: Addresses the principal safety risk for Gurdeep: I do not disclose to the father simply because he is family; I explain relevant provincial public-health and confidentiality exceptions accurately rather than promising absolute secrecy.
  • Addresses Gurdeep's concern and confirms follow-up or transfer responsibility.

Model answer

I introduce myself, confirm identity, explain the task, seek appropriate consent and protect privacy. I clean my hands before contact. I ask, "Who knows the result and whom, if anyone, do you consent to involve?" The account is: "Nobody in my family knows. I want to speak with you alone and do not consent to telling my father." I then ask, "Are you safe at home, and are there partners or others who may need support or public-health advice?" The response is: "I am worried about rejection but not immediate violence. I have a recent partner and need help knowing what to say." I review relevant medicines, allergies and background: "I understand the result and want treatment. I take no regular medicines and have no known allergies. My cell phone is the only safe contact." With an explanation and permission for each relevant examination, I assess the patient. I assess understanding and communication: Alert, coherent and able to explain his preferences. I review the supplied confirmed laboratory result: Confirmatory HIV testing is positive. No consent for disclosure to family is recorded. I explain: "A capable adult controls family disclosure; public-health duties and partner support must be explained separately from family requests." I verify the confirmed report, assess immediate wellbeing and arrange appropriate HIV specialist baseline assessment and follow-up. I protect the consultation and records from unauthorised family access, agree safe contact arrangements and explain treatment referral and confidential partner notification options. I do not disclose to the father simply because he is family; I explain relevant provincial public-health and confidentiality exceptions accurately rather than promising absolute secrecy. I respond to the main concern: "Living together does not give your father a right to your result. We will protect family privacy while explaining relevant public-health responsibilities." I document disclosure preferences, check access through portals or shared contact details and arrange a supported follow-up visit. I ask the patient or accompanying person to describe the agreed next step in their own words, respond to their questions and document the assessment and responsibilities.

What this station tests

  • A capable adult controls family disclosure; public-health duties and partner support must be explained separately from family requests.
  • I verify the confirmed report, assess immediate wellbeing and arrange appropriate HIV specialist baseline assessment and follow-up.
  • I do not disclose to the father simply because he is family; I explain relevant provincial public-health and confidentiality exceptions accurately rather than promising absolute secrecy.
  • I document disclosure preferences, check access through portals or shared contact details and arrange a supported follow-up visit.

Sources for the clinical content

An original practice scenario with invented patients. Not an exam question. Written from the guidance above and reviewed before release: how we write and check stations.

Practise next

About the NAC OSCE →