Refusing dialysis despite understanding the risk
NAC OSCE practice station
Ethics, consent & capacity · 2 min to read · 11 min to perform
Explain relevant options and agree a safe, respectful plan.
Free · no sign-up · uses your one free station
Open the full station (charts, voice, result letter) →The task
You are a doctor working in a hospital ward in Ontario, Canada. Farah Al-Salem, aged 63, is declining recommended dialysis for advanced kidney disease. The patient is present and can speak for themselves. Explore understanding, preferences and decision-making ability. Explain relevant options and agree a safe, respectful plan.
Studying with someone? Practise this station with a friend, free →
Answer for this station
What a strong answer does
- Confirms identity using reliable available sources, explains actions and seeks appropriate consent, preserving privacy without delaying emergency care.
- Elicits the presenting pattern: What do you understand dialysis could do and what could happen without it?
- Checks the patient-specific associated risks: What led to your decision, is anyone pressuring you, and are depression or symptoms affecting your thinking?
- For Farah, performs or describes how to assess current stability and attention.
- Explains the working assessment for Farah without claiming unsupported certainty.
- Selects appropriate investigations or record review for Farah, without delaying urgent care.
- Proposes the patient-specific management or shared decision plan for Farah.
- Safety: Addresses the principal safety risk for Farah: I do not ask relatives to override a capable refusal; I document the decision and any change in capacity or urgency under provincial requirements.
- Addresses Farah's concern and confirms follow-up or transfer responsibility.
Model answer
I introduce myself, confirm identity, explain the task, seek appropriate consent and protect privacy. I clean my hands before contact. I ask, "What do you understand dialysis could do and what could happen without it?" The account is: "It can treat the dangerous build-up in my blood. Without it I could become very ill or die." I then ask, "What led to your decision, is anyone pressuring you, and are depression or symptoms affecting your thinking?" The response is: "Nobody is pressuring me. I do not feel depressed or confused. The travel and burden do not fit what I want for my life." I review relevant medicines, allergies and background: "I want my family involved in support, but this is my decision. I would consider active symptom treatment and conservative kidney care." With an explanation and permission for each relevant examination, I assess the patient. I assess current stability and attention: Alert, sustained attention and clear communication; no immediate respiratory distress. I review the supplied renal team note: Progressive advanced kidney failure. Dialysis has been recommended. Conservative kidney-management options have not yet been fully discussed. I explain: "An informed voluntary refusal by a capable adult must be respected; choosing differently from clinicians does not by itself establish incapacity." I assess understanding and appreciation of the decision and its consequences, address reversible barriers and clarify the renal team recommendation. I explain benefits, material risks and conservative kidney-management options, offer renal and palliative support and explore practical help without coercion. I do not ask relatives to override a capable refusal; I document the decision and any change in capacity or urgency under provincial requirements. I respond to the main concern: "Declining dialysis does not mean losing care. Conservative kidney management and symptom support remain active options, and you can revisit your choice." I agree an active care and symptom plan, preferred family involvement and how she can reconsider treatment. I ask the patient or accompanying person to describe the agreed next step in their own words, respond to their questions and document the assessment and responsibilities.
What this station tests
- An informed voluntary refusal by a capable adult must be respected; choosing differently from clinicians does not by itself establish incapacity.
- I assess understanding and appreciation of the decision and its consequences, address reversible barriers and clarify the renal team recommendation.
- I do not ask relatives to override a capable refusal; I document the decision and any change in capacity or urgency under provincial requirements.
- I agree an active care and symptom plan, preferred family involvement and how she can reconsider treatment.
Sources for the clinical content
- Kidney failure | HealthLink BC
- CMPA: Informed consent
- Health Care Consent Act, 1996, S.O. 1996, c. 2, Sched. A
- College of Respiratory Therapists of Ontario: Capacity and consent under Ontario law
An original practice scenario with invented patients. Not an exam question. Written from the guidance above and reviewed before release: how we write and check stations.