New confusion and refusal of urgent treatment
NAC OSCE practice station
Ethics, consent & capacity · 2 min to read · 11 min to perform
Explain relevant options and agree a safe, respectful plan.
Free · no sign-up · uses your one free station
Open the full station (charts, voice, result letter) →The task
You are a doctor working in a hospital ward in Ontario, Canada. Patrick Nwosu, aged 81, presents with new confusion and refusal of treatment for a suspected infection. The patient is awake but confused. A nursing record and collateral account are supplied; his daughter can be contacted. Explore understanding, preferences and decision-making ability. Explain relevant options and agree a safe, respectful plan.
Studying with someone? Practise this station with a friend, free →
Answer for this station
What a strong answer does
- Confirms identity using reliable available sources, explains actions and seeks appropriate consent, preserving privacy without delaying emergency care.
- Elicits the presenting pattern: What do you understand about why you are in hospital and the treatment offered?
- Checks the patient-specific associated risks: Who can help us understand your usual memory and wishes, and what is upsetting you?
- For Patrick, performs or describes how to assess attention and orientation.
- Explains the working assessment for Patrick without claiming unsupported certainty.
- Selects appropriate investigations or record review for Patrick, without delaying urgent care.
- Proposes the patient-specific management or shared decision plan for Patrick.
- Safety: Addresses the principal safety risk for Patrick: I obtain the lawful substitute’s consent if the patient is incapable. If delay would cause severe suffering or serious bodily harm, necessary emergency care follows Ontario law, respecting applicable prior capable wishes and documenting the basis. I do not use restraint merely for convenience.
- Addresses Patrick's concern and confirms follow-up or transfer responsibility.
Model answer
I request urgent senior assessment of fever, tachycardia and low blood pressure and assess possible sepsis alongside delirium and treatment decision-making. I introduce myself, verify identity using the available record and explain care in simple language. I support communication and assess capacity for this treatment decision; I do not assume that refusal or confusion alone settles capacity. I clean my hands before contact. I ask, "What do you understand about why you are in hospital and the treatment offered?" The account is: "I am at the bus station. I do not know what infection you mean." I then ask, "Who can help us understand your usual memory and wishes, and what is upsetting you?" The response is: "My daughter knows me. I need my hearing aids and I am frightened by all these people." I review relevant medicines, allergies and background: "I cannot recall my medicines or allergies. My daughter brought a medication list and the ward team can verify it." With an explanation and permission for each relevant examination, I assess the patient. I assess attention and orientation: Fluctuating inattention and disorientation; cannot explain the treatment decision. I measure observations: Temperature 38.4 °C, pulse 112 beats/min, blood pressure 98/60 mmHg. I review the supplied nursing and collateral record: Daughter reports independent baseline without diagnosed dementia. Fluctuating confusion began overnight. Medication list and allergy record await verification. I explain: "Acute fluctuating inattention suggests delirium; capacity is decision specific and may fluctuate, rather than being lost simply because of age." I assess reversible causes including infection, hypoxia, glucose, pain, retention and medication effects, and verify medicines and allergies. I improve hearing and orientation, explain simply, reassess decision-making ability and identify the legally authorised substitute if he cannot make this decision, following provincial law. I obtain the lawful substitute’s consent if the patient is incapable. If delay would cause severe suffering or serious bodily harm, necessary emergency care follows Ontario law, respecting applicable prior capable wishes and documenting the basis. I do not use restraint merely for convenience. I respond to the main concern: "We will use the least restrictive approach, help you hear and understand, and involve appropriate support. Any emergency treatment must have a clear lawful basis." I document the capacity assessment, legal basis and least restrictive plan and reassess as delirium improves. I ask the patient or accompanying person to describe the agreed next step in their own words, respond to their questions and document the assessment and responsibilities.
What this station tests
- Acute fluctuating inattention suggests delirium; capacity is decision specific and may fluctuate, rather than being lost simply because of age.
- I assess reversible causes including infection, hypoxia, glucose, pain, retention and medication effects, and verify medicines and allergies.
- I obtain the lawful substitute’s consent if the patient is incapable. If delay would cause severe suffering or serious bodily harm, necessary emergency care follows Ontario law, respecting applicable prior capable wishes and documenting the basis. I do not use restraint merely for convenience.
- I document the capacity assessment, legal basis and least restrictive plan and reassess as delirium improves.
Sources for the clinical content
- Delirium: Care for Adults | Ontario Health
- CMPA: Informed consent
- Health Care Consent Act, 1996, S.O. 1996, c. 2, Sched. A
- College of Respiratory Therapists of Ontario: Capacity and consent under Ontario law
An original practice scenario with invented patients. Not an exam question. Written from the guidance above and reviewed before release: how we write and check stations.