Telling a patient about a missed result
NAC OSCE practice station
Ethics, consent & capacity · 2 min to read · 11 min to perform
Leonard Pierce, aged 61, a former smoker, comes for an appointment about a cough.
Free · no sign-up · uses your one free station
Open the full station (charts, voice, result letter) →The task
You are a family physician. Leonard Pierce, aged 61, a former smoker, comes for an appointment about a cough. While reviewing his chart you find that a chest X-ray report from four months ago, reported as showing a 2 cm nodule and advising a CT scan, was filed without anyone acting on it. He has not been told. Speak to him about this. The examiner will not take part in the conversation.
Studying with someone? Practise this station with a friend, free →
Answer for this station
What a strong answer does
- Introduces themselves, confirms identity, and arranges privacy and enough time before raising the issue.
- Takes a short focused history of symptoms and risk factors relevant to the nodule: hemoptysis, weight loss, smoking and family history.
- Safety: Discloses the error promptly and plainly: the report four months ago found a nodule, advised a CT, and nobody acted on it.
- Apologizes sincerely and takes responsibility on behalf of the practice, without blaming individuals or making excuses.
- Explains honestly what is known and not known: a nodule is not necessarily cancer, but a delay matters and needs urgent assessment.
- Responds to anger and fear with empathy, silence and clear answers to his questions about delay and outcome.
- Plans urgent action: a CT scan within days, an urgent respiratory or thoracic referral through a rapid diagnostic pathway, and follow-up call.
- Explains the process after the error: documenting the event, reporting through the practice's patient safety system, and offering a follow-up conversation and a contact for complaints.
- Offers support for the patient and his family, including help for his wife and a clear plan for communication.
- Gives a safety-net: seek urgent care or call 911 for coughing up a lot of blood, severe breathlessness or chest pain.
Model answer
I introduce myself, confirm Mr Pierce's name and date of birth, and arrange privacy and enough time. I take a brief history: a four-month cough, one episode of blood in the sputum, weight loss of 3 kg, exertional breathlessness, a 35 pack-year smoking history and a brother with lung cancer. I then disclose the error plainly and early in the conversation: the chest X-ray four months ago showed a 2 cm right upper lobe nodule, the report recommended a CT scan, and it was filed without action, so he was not told. I apologize sincerely, take responsibility for the practice without blaming individuals, and pause to let him react. I respond to his anger with empathy and honest answers. I explain that a nodule is not always cancer, but with his history we must find out urgently, and I cannot say yet whether the delay has changed the outcome. I order an urgent CT scan of the chest and refer him to a rapid diagnostic pathway for lung assessment, and I promise to call him with results and times myself. I explain that I will document the discussion in his chart, report the event through the practice's patient safety process so the system is fixed, and give him a contact for further questions or complaints. I offer support for him and his wife, and I give a safety-net: coughing up much blood, severe breathlessness or chest pain means calling 911. I check that he has understood and invite questions.
What this station tests
- Disclose the error promptly, plainly and in private; do not hide behind jargon.
- Apologize without making excuses and take responsibility for the system.
- Be honest about uncertainty, including whether the delay affected the outcome.
- Act on the clinical problem immediately: urgent CT and referral.
- Document the disclosure and report the incident so that the process can be improved.
Sources for the clinical content
An original practice scenario with invented patients. Not an exam question. Written from the guidance above and reviewed before release: how we write and check stations.