Discussing a biopsy result with a patient and daughter
NAC OSCE practice station
Breaking bad news · 2 min to read · 11 min to perform
Marion Pelletier, aged 70, is attending for biopsy results; her daughter Claire has asked privately that the result not be disclosed.
Free · no sign-up · uses your one free station
Open the full station (charts, voice, result letter) →The task
You are a doctor working in an outpatient clinic in Ontario, Canada. Marion Pelletier, aged 70, is attending for biopsy results; her daughter Claire has asked privately that the result not be disclosed. The named adult relative is present with the patient, subject to the patient's consent. Establish information preferences, discuss the supplied result sensitively and agree the next steps.
Studying with someone? Practise this station with a friend, free →
Answer for this station
What a strong answer does
- Confirms identity using reliable available sources, explains actions and seeks appropriate consent, preserving privacy without delaying emergency care.
- Elicits the presenting pattern: How much would you like to know about the result, and who would you like involved?
- Checks the patient-specific associated risks: What have you understood so far, and what worries you most?
- For Marion, performs or describes how to assess communication and attention.
- Explains the working assessment for Marion without claiming unsupported certainty.
- Selects appropriate investigations or record review for Marion, without delaying urgent care.
- Proposes the patient-specific management or shared decision plan for Marion.
- Safety: Addresses the principal safety risk for Marion: I do not collude in concealment from a capable patient who wants to know, and do not invent a prognosis or stage.
- Addresses Marion's concern and confirms follow-up or transfer responsibility.
Model answer
I introduce myself, confirm identity, explain the task, seek appropriate consent and protect privacy. I clean my hands before contact. I ask, "How much would you like to know about the result, and who would you like involved?" The account is: "I want to know everything and I want Claire here with me." I then ask, "What have you understood so far, and what worries you most?" The response is: "I know the scan showed a bowel lump. I worry about being left without choices." I review relevant medicines, allergies and background: "I am comfortable making my own decisions and have no difficulty understanding discussions. I take no regular medicines and have no known allergies." With an explanation and permission for each relevant examination, I assess the patient. I assess communication and attention: Alert, coherent and able to express stable information preferences. I review the supplied biopsy report: Colon biopsy: invasive adenocarcinoma. Staging has not yet been completed. I explain: "The patient wants full information and family involvement; the daughter’s wish to protect her does not override the patient’s preferences." I confirm identity and review the biopsy report before discussing it, distinguishing confirmed diagnosis from staging that is not yet known. I acknowledge the daughter’s concern respectfully, then tell the patient in clear short steps that the biopsy shows bowel cancer, pause and respond to emotion. I do not collude in concealment from a capable patient who wants to know, and do not invent a prognosis or stage. I respond to the main concern: "You will have a say. I will explain what the biopsy shows, what is still unknown and the options as the specialist assessment progresses." I explain specialist referral and staging next steps, offer written information and arrange follow-up with the patient’s preferred support. I ask the patient or accompanying person to describe the agreed next step in their own words, respond to their questions and document the assessment and responsibilities.
What this station tests
- The patient wants full information and family involvement; the daughter’s wish to protect her does not override the patient’s preferences.
- I confirm identity and review the biopsy report before discussing it, distinguishing confirmed diagnosis from staging that is not yet known.
- I do not collude in concealment from a capable patient who wants to know, and do not invent a prognosis or stage.
- I explain specialist referral and staging next steps, offer written information and arrange follow-up with the patient’s preferred support.
Sources for the clinical content
- Health Care Consent Act, 1996, S.O. 1996, c. 2, Sched. A
- CMPA: Informed consent
- College of Respiratory Therapists of Ontario: Capacity and consent under Ontario law
An original practice scenario with invented patients. Not an exam question. Written from the guidance above and reviewed before release: how we write and check stations.