Explaining a diagnosis of Alzheimer disease
NAC OSCE practice station
Breaking bad news · 2 min to read · 11 min to perform
Explain the results to Mrs Hrynyk and her daughter and plan the next steps.
Free · no sign-up · uses your one free station
Open the full station (charts, voice, result letter) →The task
You are a family physician in a community clinic. Eleanor Hrynyk, aged 78, has had two years of worsening memory. Tests including blood work, a cognitive assessment and a brain MRI have been completed and are consistent with Alzheimer disease. She has come with her daughter, Natalie, to hear the results. Explain the results to Mrs Hrynyk and her daughter and plan the next steps. The examiner will not take part in the conversation.
Studying with someone? Practise this station with a friend, free →
Answer for this station
What a strong answer does
- Introduces themselves, confirms identity and sets up the discussion with both, asking what they understand and want to know.
- Gives a warning shot and then states the diagnosis clearly, in plain words, to the patient first.
- Explains the supporting evidence: the cognitive score, the MRI changes and normal reversible-cause tests.
- Safety: Responds to emotion with empathy, pauses and checks understanding; respects the patient's right to the truth when the daughter asks to soften it.
- Explains that the illness is progressive but that people live well for years with support, and avoids false hope or false doom.
- Discusses treatment options: a cholinesterase inhibitor can be considered, helps symptoms modestly and does not cure.
- Raises safety and driving: driving risk after getting lost and a collision, and the physician's duties under provincial rules.
- Advises planning while she can decide: power of attorney, wishes for care and finances; refers to the Alzheimer Society and community supports.
- Supports the caregiver, acknowledging her worries about work and cost, and arranges follow-up with the family.
- Gives a clear next-step plan and follow-up, and safety-nets for sudden changes such as new confusion, falls or thoughts of self-harm, including calling 911.
Model answer
I introduce myself to both women, confirm Mrs Hrynyk's name and date of birth, and ask what she understands and how much she wants to know. She asks for plain truth, while Natalie asks me to be gentle. I give a warning shot, then tell Mrs Hrynyk clearly that the memory test, a score of 17 out of 30, and the MRI showing shrinkage of the memory area point to Alzheimer disease, and that treatable causes such as thyroid and B12 problems have been excluded. I pause, acknowledge her feelings, and respect her right to be told while reassuring Natalie that I will be careful. I explain that the illness is progressive but that people can live well for years. I discuss treatment honestly: a cholinesterase inhibitor such as donepezil may help symptoms modestly and does not cure. I explore safety: she got lost driving and had a collision, so driving is a concern, and I explain that she needs a driving assessment or to stop, and my reporting duties under provincial rules. While she can still decide, I recommend setting up a power of attorney, discussing her wishes for care and finances, and linking with the Alzheimer Society for support. I acknowledge Natalie's burden, mention home care and respite services, arrange follow-up in about a month, and safety-net for sudden confusion, falls or thoughts of self-harm, calling 911 in an emergency.
What this station tests
- Ask what the patient wants to know, give a warning shot, then say the diagnosis plainly.
- Respect the patient's right to know even when family ask for the news to be softened.
- Cover driving, safety, legal planning and caregiver support in the same visit.
- Describe treatment honestly: symptomatic benefit only.
- Plan follow-up and link families to the Alzheimer Society.
Sources for the clinical content
- 5th Canadian Consensus Conference on the diagnosis and treatment of dementia
- Alzheimer Society of Canada: planning your future
An original practice scenario with invented patients. Not an exam question. Written from the guidance above and reviewed before release: how we write and check stations.