Painful stiff shoulder after a fall
PLAB 2 practice station
Examination · 1 min to read · 8 min to perform
Examine her right shoulder.
Free · no sign-up · uses your one free station
Open the full station (charts, voice, result letter) →The task
You are a doctor in the emergency department. Mrs Pauline Hadley, aged 59, slipped on an icy path four days ago and landed on her right shoulder. It is still very painful and she cannot lift her arm. She is sitting on the couch with her top removed to a vest. Examine her right shoulder. Say aloud what you are doing at each step. The examiner will report the findings when you say what you are doing. At the end, summarise your findings, say what you think is going on and what you would do next.
Studying with someone? Practise this station with a friend, free →
Answer for this station
What a strong answer does
- Washes hands, introduces self, confirms name and date of birth, explains the examination, obtains consent and exposes both shoulders appropriately.
- Asks about mechanism, site of pain, handedness, function, night pain, numbness and past shoulder or neck problems.
- Inspects both shoulders from the front, side and behind and compares the sides.
- Palpates systematically, including the clavicle, acromioclavicular joint, greater tuberosity and proximal humerus, checking for tenderness and steps.
- Assesses active and passive movements in all planes, comparing them and noting the pain and limitation.
- Performs rotator cuff tests: drop arm, empty can, resisted external rotation, lift-off, and painful arc or impingement tests, and interprets them.
- Safety: Tests axillary nerve sensation and deltoid power, checks radial pulse, capillary refill and hand sensation, and examines the neck.
- Requests a shoulder X-ray to exclude fracture or dislocation and explains why.
- Summarises findings and gives a reasoned diagnosis: suspected acute traumatic rotator cuff tear, probably supraspinatus, with fracture and dislocation excluded on X-ray.
- Gives a management plan: analgesia, a short period in a sling, early gentle movement, safety-netting, and urgent referral to orthopaedics or a shoulder clinic with ultrasound or MRI, because an acute traumatic tear may need early repair.
- Responds to her concerns about surgery and caring for her grandson, explains recovery honestly, and checks her understanding.
Model answer
I wash my hands, introduce myself, confirm Mrs Hadley’s name and date of birth, explain that I would like to examine her shoulder, obtain consent and ask her to expose both shoulders. I ask her to tell me if anything hurts. I ask how she fell, what she landed on, whether she hit her head, where it hurts, her handedness, night pain, numbness, past shoulder and neck problems, and risk factors for fracture. I inspect from the front, the side and behind, and compare both sides: the examiner reports swelling and bruising over the lateral upper arm without deformity. I palpate the clavicle, acromioclavicular joint, acromion and greater tuberosity: tender over the greater tuberosity and subacromial region. I assess active and passive movement: active abduction is limited to 50 degrees with shoulder hitching, passive movement is better. I do the drop arm test, which is positive, test supraspinatus with the empty can test (weak), infraspinatus and subscapularis, and a painful arc. I test axillary nerve sensation and deltoid power, check the radial pulse, capillary refill and hand sensation, and examine the neck. These are normal. I request an X-ray, which shows no fracture or dislocation. I summarise: a painful shoulder after a fall with weak, painful abduction, a positive drop arm test and a painful arc, most likely an acute rotator cuff tear involving supraspinatus. I explain the plan: regular analgesia, a sling for comfort for a few days only, early movement and physiotherapy, and urgent referral to a shoulder clinic for an ultrasound or MRI to look for a full-thickness tear that may need early repair. I safety-net and address her concerns about surgery and caring for her grandson.
What this station tests
- Examine any joint in the order look, feel, move, special tests, and always compare with the other side.
- After a fall, exclude fracture and dislocation with an X-ray before attributing pain to soft tissue injury.
- Check axillary nerve sensation (regimental badge area) and distal pulses after a shoulder injury.
- A positive drop arm test and marked supraspinatus weakness after trauma suggest an acute rotator cuff tear. Refer urgently for imaging and specialist review, because early repair gives the best results for some tears.
- Active movement much worse than passive movement points to a muscle or tendon problem; equal loss of both suggests a capsular or bony problem.
- Keep the sling use short to avoid a stiff shoulder.
Sources for the clinical content
An original practice scenario with invented patients. Not an exam question. Written from the guidance above and reviewed before release: how we write and check stations.