Coughing up blood for two weeks
PLAB 2 practice station

History taking · 1 min to read · 8 min to perform

Try a real conversation · PLAB 2AI practice

Take a focused history, ask the examiner for any examination findings you need, explain what you think could be happening and agree what happens next.

Barry WhitlockMorning, doctor. My wife made me come. I’ve been coughing up a bit of blood and she won’t let it drop.

Free · no sign-up · uses your one free station

The task

You are a GP. Mr Barry Whitlock, aged 67, has come to the surgery because he has been coughing up blood for two weeks. He is alone. Take a focused history, ask the examiner for any examination findings you need, explain what you think could be happening and agree what happens next. The examiner will not take part in the conversation.

Answer for this station

What a strong answer does

  • Introduces self, confirms name and date of birth, and opens with a question that lets him tell his story.
  • Characterises the haemoptysis: amount, colour, frothiness, duration, pattern, and whether it is true haemoptysis rather than blood from the nose or stomach.
  • Safety: Asks about weight loss, appetite, night sweats, fever, breathlessness, chest pain, and a change in voice.
  • Takes a smoking history and an occupational history including asbestos exposure.
  • Considers other causes: infection, pulmonary embolism risk, tuberculosis risk, bleeding tendency, and anticoagulant use.
  • Explores his ideas, concerns and expectations, including the family history that explains his fear.
  • Requests relevant examination: observations including oxygen saturation, hands for clubbing, neck nodes, chest, and legs.
  • Safety: Explains honestly that persistent haemoptysis in a smoker needs urgent investigation, that cancer is one possibility but not the only one, and makes a suspected cancer pathway referral, with an urgent chest X-ray.
  • Responds with empathy to his fear and his brother’s death without false reassurance, and avoids confirming a diagnosis.
  • Offers support to stop smoking and gives safety-netting: ring 999 for heavy bleeding, severe breathlessness or chest pain; and who will contact him with results.
  • Summarises, checks his understanding and agrees to involve his wife if he wishes.

Model answer

I introduce myself, confirm Mr Whitlock’s name and date of birth and ask him to tell me about the blood. It has been streaks of bright red blood in his sputum most days for two weeks, never more than a teaspoon, with a worsening cough that did not improve with antibiotics. I ask about weight loss, appetite, night sweats, fever, breathlessness, chest pain and hoarseness, and he has lost six kilos, is more breathless, has a dull right-sided ache and a croaky voice. I take a smoking history, twenty a day since sixteen, and an occupational history of pipe lagging and shipyard work with probable asbestos exposure. I screen for other causes: no leg swelling, travel or surgery, no TB contacts, no anticoagulants. I explore his ideas and concerns, and learn that his brother died of lung cancer. I ask for observations, hands, neck nodes, chest and legs. The examiner reports clubbing, reduced air entry and dullness at the right base, no nodes, and normal observations. I explain honestly that blood in the phlegm for this long, with weight loss, in a long-term smoker, needs urgent tests. I say that lung cancer is a real possibility but that I cannot say it is that. I refer him on the suspected cancer pathway today, arrange an urgent chest X-ray, and explain that the hospital will contact him quickly and who will give him the results. I acknowledge his fear about his brother, avoid false reassurance and offer to involve his wife. I offer help to stop smoking. I give safety-netting: call 999 for heavy bleeding, severe breathlessness or chest pain. I summarise and check his understanding.

What this station tests

  • NICE NG12: anyone aged 40 or over with unexplained haemoptysis should be referred on a suspected cancer pathway; an urgent chest X-ray is also useful but must not hold up the referral.
  • Ask about asbestos and occupation: it changes the likelihood of lung and pleural disease.
  • Always consider other causes such as infection, pulmonary embolism and tuberculosis, but do not let them delay urgent investigation.
  • Voice changes, weight loss and clubbing add weight to concern.
  • Be honest without confirming a diagnosis you do not have; name the fear and respond to it.
  • Safety-net for heavy bleeding with 999.

Sources for the clinical content

An original practice scenario with invented patients. Not an exam question. Written from the guidance above and reviewed before release: how we write and check stations.

Practise next

About the PLAB 2 →