Mother worried about her daughter's eating
PLAB 2 practice station

History taking · 1 min to read · 8 min to perform

Try a real conversation · PLAB 2AI practice

Take a history from Mrs Kirkby, tell her what you think and agree a plan.

Joanne KirkbyI’m sorry to come on my own. I’m really worried about Ruby. She’s hardly eating and she’s lost loads of weight. She doesn’t know I’m here.

Free · no sign-up · uses your one free station

The task

You are a GP. Mrs Joanne Kirkby has come, without her 15-year-old daughter Ruby, because she is worried about Ruby’s eating and weight. Ruby does not know she is here. Take a history from Mrs Kirkby, tell her what you think and agree a plan. You have not met Ruby recently and no records are available to you today. The examiner will not take part in the conversation.

Answer for this station

What a strong answer does

  • Introduces self, builds rapport, acknowledges her worry and guilt, and invites her to describe her concerns without interrupting.
  • Takes a history of weight loss, eating behaviours, compensatory behaviours (exercise, laxatives, vomiting) and body image concerns.
  • Safety: Asks about physical red flags: periods, dizziness, fainting, palpitations, cold intolerance.
  • Asks about mood, self-harm, suicidal thoughts, school, friendships and triggers.
  • Safety: Explains that this sounds like a possible eating disorder that needs prompt assessment, and that GPs cannot diagnose or treat without seeing Ruby.
  • Is honest about confidentiality: can listen, but cannot promise secrecy; encourages telling Ruby openly; Ruby has her own right to confidentiality if she attends.
  • Advises how to approach Ruby: calm, caring, non-blaming, avoids focusing on weight or arguments over food, and offers a joint appointment.
  • Outlines the plan: Ruby seen today or tomorrow given the fainting and laxatives, examination, bloods and ECG, urgent referral to a community child and adolescent eating disorder service, and what to do if Ruby refuses; explains that Ruby cannot be forced to eat but that treatment is available and parental involvement matters.
  • Safety: Safety-nets: take her to the emergency department or call 999 if she faints, has chest pain, palpitations, severe weakness or talks of self-harm.
  • Supports the mother, checks understanding, provides written information, and documents the discussion.

Model answer

I give my name and GMC number, introduce myself and ask Mrs Kirkby what she has noticed. I listen and acknowledge how hard it was to come. I ask about the amount and speed of Ruby’s weight loss, her eating habits, counting calories, exercise, laxatives and vomiting. I ask about red flags: her periods stopping, dizziness, fainting last week, tiredness and feeling cold. I ask about her mood, school, friends, triggers and the cuts on her thigh, and about suicidal thoughts. I explain that the history is concerning for an eating disorder, a serious but treatable illness, and that Ruby needs prompt assessment, including an examination, blood tests and an ECG. I explain that I cannot diagnose without seeing her and that early treatment gives the best outcome. I am honest about confidentiality: I can listen to her, but I cannot promise to keep her visit secret from Ruby, and I encourage her to tell Ruby calmly that she is worried because she loves her, avoiding arguments about weight or food. If Ruby attends, what she tells me is confidential within the usual safety limits. I offer Ruby an appointment today or tomorrow because of the fainting and laxatives, and plan an urgent referral to the community child and adolescent eating disorder service. If Ruby will not come, I ask her mother to ring me the same day, and I take advice from the eating disorder team and our safeguarding lead, because refusal does not end our concern. I explain that she cannot force Ruby to eat, but that family support matters. I safety-net: call 999 or go to the emergency department for fainting, chest pain, palpitations, severe weakness or talk of self-harm. I reassure her that it is not her fault, give written information and document.

What this station tests

  • Take the history from the parent but plan to see the young person; a GP cannot diagnose from a parent’s account alone.
  • Ask about physical red flags (syncope, amenorrhoea, palpitations) and self-harm.
  • Be honest about confidentiality; do not promise secrecy to the parent.
  • Refer early to a specialist eating disorder service; do not wait for a weight threshold.
  • Safety-net for fainting, chest pain, palpitations and suicidal talk.

Sources for the clinical content

An original practice scenario with invented patients. Not an exam question. Written from the guidance above and reviewed before release: how we write and check stations.

Practise next

About the PLAB 2 →