Tired, sore knees and asking about her weight
PLAB 2 practice station
Counselling & explanation · 1 min to read · 8 min to perform
Mrs Shirin Moghaddam, aged 41, has come about tiredness and sore knees.
Free · no sign-up · uses your one free station
Open the full station (charts, voice, result letter) →The task
You are a GP. Mrs Shirin Moghaddam, aged 41, has come about tiredness and sore knees. Her weight was measured by the nurse and her body mass index is 34. She has asked what she can do about her weight. She is alone. Explore her situation, offer advice and agree a plan. The examiner will not take part in the conversation.
Studying with someone? Practise this station with a friend, free →
Answer for this station
What a strong answer does
- Introduces self, asks permission to discuss weight, and uses respectful, non-judgemental language.
- Explores weight history, diet, activity, sleep, mood, stress and previous attempts.
- Identifies contributing factors, including a medicine that may increase appetite, and asks about thyroid symptoms and sleep apnoea features.
- Requests weight, height, BMI, waist, blood pressure and blood tests including HbA1c, full blood count and thyroid function.
- Explains the health risks of obesity honestly without blame, and links to her tiredness, knees and diabetes worry.
- Explores her expectations and sets a realistic goal, such as a modest, sustained loss of 5 to 10% over several months rather than a rapid target.
- Gives practical advice on diet and activity: regular meals, fewer sugary drinks and snacks, portions, and gentle low-impact activity building towards 150 minutes a week.
- Safety: Offers referral to a weight management programme and discusses weight-loss medicines honestly: an option only for people who meet set criteria, prescribed and monitored by a clinician alongside diet and activity, and not bought online without supervision.
- Reviews her medicine, suggests she discusses it rather than stopping mirtazapine herself, and offers support for mood and sleep.
- Checks understanding, agrees a follow-up, gives written information and ends supportively.
Model answer
I introduce myself, ask permission to discuss weight and use respectful language. I ask about her weight history, previous diets, eating pattern, activity, sleep, mood and stress. She gained weight after her second baby and again after starting mirtazapine, eats irregularly and relies on sugary drinks. I ask about thyroid symptoms, snoring and periods, and about what she hopes for. She wants a quick fix and fears diabetes. I review her weight of 88 kg and height of 1.61 m, giving a BMI of 34, with a waist of 98 cm, normal blood pressure, a normal HbA1c, and normal blood count, ferritin and thyroid function. Her waist-to-height ratio is 0.61, which is high. I explain without blame how weight relates to her knee pain, tiredness and diabetes risk, and that her sugar test is currently reassuring. I discuss realistic goals: a gradual loss of 5 to 10% of body weight, sustained, rather than a fast target. I suggest regular meals, fewer sugary drinks and snacks, portion awareness and low-impact activity such as swimming or cycling, building towards 150 minutes weekly. I offer referral to a tier 2 weight management programme, with evening options. I explain that weight-loss medicines are only for people who meet set criteria, prescribed and monitored alongside lifestyle change, and that buying them online without supervision is unsafe, and I advise her not to stop mirtazapine alone but to review it with me. I offer help with sleep and mood. I check her understanding, agree a review in a month with repeat weight, give written information, and document the discussion.
What this station tests
- Ask permission to discuss weight and avoid blame or stigmatising language.
- Consider contributing medicines, mood, sleep and medical causes.
- Set realistic goals: modest sustained weight loss of 5 to 10% brings health benefits.
- Offer multicomponent lifestyle programmes first; weight-loss medicines are for people who meet NICE criteria, with lower BMI thresholds for some ethnic groups, and need clinical supervision.
- Advise against stopping psychiatric medicines abruptly.
- Use waist-to-height ratio alongside BMI: 0.5 or more means raised central fat.
Sources for the clinical content
An original practice scenario with invented patients. Not an exam question. Written from the guidance above and reviewed before release: how we write and check stations.