A son asks about his father's prescriptions
PEBC OSCE practice station
Ethics, consent & capacity · 2 min to read · 7 min to perform
Mr Daniel Cheung, aged 45, comes to the counter and asks for a printout of all the medicines his father, Mr Harold Cheung, aged 78, takes and when they were last filled.
Free · no sign-up · uses your one free station
Open the full station (charts, voice, result letter) →The task
You are a pharmacist in a community pharmacy. Mr Daniel Cheung, aged 45, comes to the counter and asks for a printout of all the medicines his father, Mr Harold Cheung, aged 78, takes and when they were last filled. His father is not present. The father's pharmacy profile is in the patient folder. Decide how to respond, discuss it with Mr Cheung, and agree on a plan that protects the father and addresses the son's concern. The assessor will not take part in the conversation.
Studying with someone? Practise this station with a friend, free →
Answer for this station
What a strong answer does
- Introduces self, treats the son courteously and clarifies his identity and relationship to the patient.
- Safety: Explains clearly and kindly that he cannot disclose the father's health information, including the medicine list, without the father's consent, and explains why.
- Safety: Respects the note in the profile and does not confirm or reveal any specific medicine, diagnosis or fill dates while still listening.
- Explores the son's concern and the father's capacity to decide, asking about confusion, safety risks and who has legal authority.
- Takes the concern seriously: receives the information he offers and agrees to act on it, such as calling the father or arranging an in-person review.
- Offers practical options that respect autonomy: ask the father for consent to share, invite the father to attend with his son, offer blister packs or a pill organizer and a medication review.
- Recognizes the limit of confidentiality in an emergency or when there is a serious risk, and advises what to do if the father is in danger, including calling 911.
- Answers his question about what to say to his father, advising an honest, caring conversation.
- Documents the contact and the plan to follow up with the patient, without disclosing the son's visit unless appropriate.
Model answer
I greet Mr Cheung's son, introduce myself and ask his name and relationship. I listen to his concern. Before offering anything, I check the profile and see that his father has signed a note asking that no information be shared with family without his permission. I explain kindly and clearly that I cannot give out a medication list or fill dates without his father's consent, that the rule protects every patient, and that it is not a judgment about him. I do not confirm or deny any medicine. I then turn to what I can do. I ask what he has noticed and learn about duplicated, open bottles and an unfamiliar medicine. I ask whether his father makes his own decisions and whether there is a power of attorney, and I learn there is none and that he is independent. I thank him for the information, which I can receive without disclosing anything in return. I explain that I will contact his father today, offer a medication review and, if he agrees, blister packaging or another system. I explain that the father can give permission to share the list, and invite the father to come with his son so that they can talk it through together. I mention that if there is ever an emergency, with immediate danger, he should call 911. I suggest he speak honestly and caringly with his father and respect his choice. I document the conversation and the plan to follow up with his father. I acknowledge his worry and thank him for caring.
What this station tests
- Privacy applies to family members; patient consent is the key.
- Listening is allowed; disclosing is not.
- Don't leave the person with a flat refusal: offer a way forward.
- Respect a patient's written wishes in the profile.
- Serious risk or emergency changes the response; know who to call.
Sources for the clinical content
- Office of the Privacy Commissioner of Canada: PIPEDA
- Office of the Privacy Commissioner of Canada: provincial and territorial privacy laws
- NAPRA: Model Standards of Practice for Pharmacists and Pharmacy Technicians in Canada
An original practice scenario with invented patients. Not an exam question. Written from the guidance above and reviewed before release: how we write and check stations.