A photo of a patient's leg on a colleague's phone
NZ nursing OSCE practice station

Ethics, consent & capacity · 2 min to read · 8 min to perform

Try a real conversation · NZ nursing OSCEAI practice

Grant Pickering, aged 67, has a leg ulcer.

Grant PickeringThat young fella took a photo of my bare leg on his own phone. Nobody asked me.

Free · no sign-up · uses your one free station

The task

You are the nurse on a medical ward in New Zealand. Grant Pickering, aged 67, has a leg ulcer. He tells you he saw a health care assistant, Jake, take a photo of his leg with a personal phone and he is upset. Jake is nearby. The charge nurse manager can be reached by phone. Talk with Mr Pickering, then speak with Jake. Decide what must be done about privacy and consent, who must be told and what to say to Mr Pickering. Record your actions.

Answer for this station

What a strong answer does

  • Listens to Mr Pickering without defensiveness, acknowledges his distress and apologises for what happened.
  • Establishes facts: what was taken, when, whether consent was given and what he fears.
  • Safety: Recognises it as a breach of privacy and consent, and of the Health Information Privacy Code and Code of Rights.
  • Speaks to Jake privately, factually and without humiliating him, to find out where the photo went.
  • Stops further sharing and keeps a record of recipients before deletion, per the manager's plan, rather than deleting or ignoring.
  • Safety: Reports to the charge nurse manager promptly, with a clear ISBAR account, and does not agree to cover up.
  • Tells Mr Pickering honestly what happens next, including deletion, a manager meeting, written follow-up and the right to complain to the HDC or the Privacy Commissioner.
  • Reassures him about his care, continues the dressing plan and keeps his dignity.
  • Documents the incident factually and completes the incident report.

Model answer

I sit with Mr Pickering, listen without interrupting and tell him I am sorry this happened. He says a health care assistant photographed his leg and part of his face on a personal phone without asking, and that he fears it has been shared. I ask what he wants to happen: he wants the photo deleted, to know who saw it, and for it not to happen again. I check the chart and find no record of consent for photography, and I check that his leg and dressing are fine. I recognise this as a breach of his privacy and of his right to be treated with respect and to give or refuse consent under the Code of Health and Disability Services Consumers' Rights, and a matter for the Health Information Privacy Code. I speak to Jake privately and calmly. He tells me he meant to ask a nurse friend for advice about the dressing and posted the photo in a group chat of eight people by mistake. I ask him to stop sharing it and to wait before deleting it so the recipients can be recorded. I telephone the charge nurse manager, Sarita Patel, and give a factual ISBAR account, and I read back her plan to manage the deletion with the privacy officer and see Mr Pickering today. I do not hide the incident. I tell Mr Pickering honestly what will happen: a manager meeting today, a written response, deletion by everyone who received it, and his right to complain to the Health and Disability Commissioner or the Privacy Commissioner. I complete an incident report and record the facts.

What this station tests

  • Patient photographs need informed consent and an approved device. Personal phones are not acceptable.
  • Listen, apologise and ask what the patient wants. Then tell him honestly what happens next.
  • Report a privacy breach promptly to the manager and privacy officer. Do not try to fix it quietly.
  • Speak to the colleague privately and factually. Preserve the facts before deletion.
  • Patients can complain to the Health and Disability Commissioner or, for privacy, the Privacy Commissioner, so tell them.

Sources for the clinical content

An original practice scenario with invented patients. Not an exam question. Written from the guidance above and reviewed before release: how we write and check stations.

Practise next

About the NZ nursing OSCE →