A patient who declines her prescribed insulin
NMC OSCE practice station
Ethics, consent & capacity · 1 min to read · 15 min to perform
Complete the record.
Free · no sign-up · uses your one free station
Open the full station (charts, voice, result letter) →The task
You are a registered nurse on a medical ward. Kalpana Iyer, aged 67, has type 2 diabetes and was admitted with a chest infection. Her blood glucose has been high, and the doctor has prescribed insulin for the next few days. You go to give the first dose and she says she does not want it. You are the only nurse available and the doctor is on call by phone. Talk with her about her decision, work out what to do, and tell the doctor. Complete the record.
Studying with someone? Practise this station with a friend, free →
Answer for this station
What a strong answer does
- Introduces self, checks identity and responds calmly and respectfully, without trying to force or persuade her.
- Explores her reasons, fears and understanding of the illness.
- Starts from the presumption of capacity and checks that her decision is informed: she can understand, retain and weigh the information and communicate her choice.
- Gives balanced information in plain words about benefits and risks of insulin and of declining, including low sugars, and does not coerce or threaten.
- Safety: Respects that a capable adult may make an unwise decision, and does not give the insulin or hide it.
- Explores alternatives and support: diabetes team, tablets, smaller needles, hypoglycaemia teaching, and offers to revisit the choice.
- Continues safe care: monitors glucose, ketones and observations, and tells her when she should call for help.
- Tells the doctor promptly with a clear SBAR handover and agrees a plan.
- Documents the reasons, information, capacity assessment, decision and plan, signed and timed.
Model answer
I introduce myself, check Mrs Iyer's name and wristband and sit down with her. I tell her I am not here to force anything and I ask what worries her. She tells me about her sister's collapse with a low sugar, her fear of needles and her belief that insulin means her diabetes is much worse. I thank her for being honest. I start from the position that she has capacity, as the Mental Capacity Act 2005 requires, and I check it for this decision. I ask her what the insulin is for and what might happen if she does not have it. She explains in her own words, understands the risks, weighs them up and says clearly that she wants to try without it. She understands, retains, weighs and communicates, so she has capacity, and her choice, even if I think it unwise, is hers. I do not give the insulin, hide it or threaten her. I give balanced information in plain words: insulin brings the sugar down faster but can cause low sugars; declining may mean her sugar stays high and she takes longer to recover. I offer a chat with the diabetes nurse about the needles and low sugars, and say that we can ask her again tomorrow. I check her blood glucose, which is 16.4 mmol/L, her ketones 0.4 mmol/L and her observations, which are stable, and I tell her what to call me for. I phone Dr Reddy with an SBAR handover: that she has declined, her reasons, the glucose and ketones, the observations, my assessment of her capacity, and I ask for review and a plan. I record her reasons, the information given, the capacity assessment, her decision and the plan, signed and timed.
What this station tests
- Presume capacity. When a refusal could cause harm, check that she can understand, retain and weigh the information and communicate her choice, for this decision.
- A capable adult can refuse treatment, even if the decision seems unwise; never coerce or disguise medicines.
- Explore the reasons for refusal; fear and misunderstanding can often be addressed and the choice revisited.
- Keep monitoring and keep the offer open, with clear advice on when to call for help.
- Tell the prescriber, hand over using SBAR and document the reasons, capacity assessment and plan.
Sources for the clinical content
An original practice scenario with invented patients. Not an exam question. Written from the guidance above and reviewed before release: how we write and check stations.