A colleague who smells of alcohol before a shift
NMC OSCE practice station

Professional values · 1 min to read · 10 min to perform

Open this station

A written station. Free to try, no sign-up.

The task

You are a registered nurse arriving for an early shift on a medical ward. At the start of handover you notice that Gethin, a staff nurse you have worked with for two years, smells strongly of alcohol, has slightly slurred speech and is due to give out the morning medicines. He says he is fine and you should not worry. In the response sheet, write what you would do, explain why, and say what you would do afterwards.

Answer for this station

What a strong answer does

  • Safety: Puts patient safety first: ensures Gethin does not give medicines or provide care until the situation is assessed.
  • Safety: Acts promptly and tells the nurse in charge or ward manager straight away.
  • Speaks to the colleague privately and calmly with concern, without accusing or diagnosing.
  • Describes only what was seen, heard and smelt, and does not assume the cause.
  • Recognises that he may be unwell or in need of support and ensures he is not left alone or unsupported.
  • Cites the Code duty to raise concerns and the trust policy, including occupational health and Freedom to Speak Up.
  • Records the facts and ensures patients are safely covered, for example by reallocating tasks.
  • Follows up: checks the outcome, escalates higher if no action is taken, and reflects on the experience.

Model answer

My first thought is patient safety. Gethin smells of alcohol and his speech is slurred, and he is about to give out medicines, so he must not give medicines or care for patients until a senior colleague has assessed him. I would not assume a cause: he might be unwell, but alcohol is a real possibility. I would speak to him privately, calmly and with concern, saying what I have noticed, and I would then go to the nurse in charge straight away. If he refused to stop or I could not speak to him safely, I would go to the nurse in charge first without delay. I would give the nurse in charge a factual account: what I smelt and heard, when, and that he was about to give medicines, and I would not accuse him. The nurse in charge can then arrange cover for his patients and manage the situation using the trust policy, which may include sending him home safely, not driving, and involving occupational health. The NMC Code requires me to raise concerns immediately if patients could be at risk and to act without delay, and I have a duty to put patient safety before loyalty to a colleague. Afterwards I would write down the facts and the time, and check that Gethin has support and is not left alone if he is unwell. If no action were taken I would escalate to the matron or the Freedom to Speak Up guardian. I would reflect on the situation and ask for supervision, because it is difficult to report a friend.

What this station tests

  • Patient safety comes first: someone who may be unfit to work must not give care or medicines.
  • Raise the concern at once with the nurse in charge; do not wait to see if it settles.
  • Report what you saw, heard and smelt, without guessing the cause.
  • Colleagues who struggle with alcohol need support as well as safe action; use occupational health and trust policy.
  • If your concern is not acted on, escalate, using the Freedom to Speak Up guardian.

Sources for the clinical content

An original practice scenario with invented patients. Not an exam question. Written from the guidance above and reviewed before release: how we write and check stations.

Practise next

About the NMC OSCE →