A student asks you to sign off a skill you did not observe
NMC OSCE practice station

Professional values · 1 min to read · 10 min to perform

Open this station

A written station. Free to try, no sign-up.

The task

You are a registered nurse on a surgical ward and are acting as practice supervisor for a second-year student nurse, Kayode, who is waiting for assessment of a skill. At the end of a busy shift, Kayode shows you his practice document and says he has done a catheter care procedure on his own with a patient while you were with another patient. He asks you to sign the skill as achieved because the document is due in tomorrow. In the response sheet, write what you would say and do, explain why, and say what you would do next.

Answer for this station

What a strong answer does

  • Safety: Refuses, clearly and kindly, to sign for a skill they did not observe.
  • Explains that signing would be dishonest and falsifies a record, and links this to the Code (honesty, accurate records).
  • Checks the patient was safe and well after the unsupervised procedure and looks at the catheter care.
  • Explains that he should not carry out a skill he has not yet been assessed in without the agreed level of supervision, and tells the practice assessor or ward manager.
  • Supports the student: stays supportive, offers to observe on the next shift or arranges another supervisor.
  • Does not accept deadline pressure as a reason; offers to help seek an extension from the university.
  • Records what happened and gives constructive feedback, including the importance of asking before acting alone.
  • Reflects on supervision arrangements and learning, and on how to prevent this happening again.

Model answer

I would speak to Kayode privately and kindly, and say that I cannot sign the skill because I did not see him do it. My signature confirms that I observed the procedure and that he was competent, so signing without having seen it would be dishonest and would falsify a record. The NMC Code requires honesty, accurate records and putting safety first, and the NMC standards for student supervision and assessment expect decisions about a student's skills to be based on what supervisors and assessors have actually seen. Before anything else I would check on the patient and the catheter care, and ask Kayode what he did, so that I know the patient is safe and well. I would tell him that he should not carry out a skill he has not yet been assessed in without the agreed supervision, and I would explain this as a learning point, not to shame him. I would offer to observe him do the skill on the next shift, or arrange for another practice supervisor if I am not on, and I would say the deadline is not a good enough reason to sign. I would suggest that he asks the university about an extension and I would help him make the request. I would tell the practice assessor and the ward manager that he did a procedure unsupervised, because they need to know and can support him, and I would write what happened and the plan in the record. Afterwards I would reflect on how I plan supervision, so that students can always find someone to supervise them when they need to practise a skill.

What this station tests

  • Only sign for what you have seen: your signature is a statement of fact.
  • Falsifying a record, even to help someone, breaches the Code.
  • Check the patient first when care has been given without supervision.
  • Be supportive: offer a clear plan to observe the skill soon rather than just refusing.
  • Tell the practice assessor so the student gets the right support and learning.

Sources for the clinical content

An original practice scenario with invented patients. Not an exam question. Written from the guidance above and reviewed before release: how we write and check stations.

Practise next

About the NMC OSCE →