Appraising a small audit about falls prevention
NMC OSCE practice station
Evidence-based practice · 1 min to read · 10 min to perform
A written station. Free to try, no sign-up.
The task
You are a registered nurse on an older people's ward. The ward manager has asked you to read the audit summary in the folder, which reports a falls prevention project on one ward, and to tell her what it shows. In the response sheet, explain what the audit found and how far the results can be trusted. Then say what you would recommend for your ward and what you would want to find out next.
Studying with someone? Practise this station with a friend, free →
Answer for this station
What a strong answer does
- States the process finding accurately: assessment within 24 hours rose from 60 % (48 of 80) to 85 % (68 of 80), below the 90 % target.
- Calculates and reports the falls rates correctly: 13 per 2,100 bed days is 6.2 per 1,000 and 10 per 2,130 is 4.7 per 1,000.
- Recognises that the number of falls is small so the fall in rate could be due to chance, and that the audit cannot show the project caused the change.
- Identifies the weakness in how records were chosen and who audited them: the ward sister chose the records and also carried out the audit.
- Identifies other limits: one ward, no comparison, small sample, before-and-after timing and season, only reported falls.
- Distinguishes an audit of practice against a standard from research, and recognises what an audit can and cannot show.
- Gives a safe, proportionate recommendation: encouraging, continue and improve the project, but do not roll out hospital-wide on this evidence alone.
- Says what to find out next: re-audit with random records and independent checkers, track falls and harm over longer time, and compare with NICE guidance.
- Safety: Keeps patient safety first: does not reduce falls precautions while the evidence is uncertain, and involves the team in feedback.
Model answer
This is an audit on one ward, not a research study, so it checks practice against a standard. The standard was a multifactorial falls assessment within 24 hours of admission, with a target of 90 percent. Before the project 48 of 80 records met it, which is 60 percent. After the project, 68 of 80 met it, which is 85 percent. That is a 25 percentage point improvement, and the process is better, but the 90 percent target was not reached. Falls fell from 13 over 2,100 occupied bed days to 10 over 2,130 bed days. As rates, that is 6.2 per 1,000 bed days before and 4.7 per 1,000 bed days after, a drop of 1.5. The numbers of falls are small, so this could easily be chance. I would not trust the conclusion that the project reduced falls. It covers one ward with no comparison ward. A before-and-after design cannot show cause, because the season, staffing and patient mix may have changed. Eighty records is a small sample, and the ward sister both chose the records and carried out the audit, so bias is possible. Only reported falls were counted, and the severity of falls is not described. There was no statistical test. My recommendation is that the improvement in assessments is encouraging and we should keep using the prompt card and weekly checks, aiming for 90 percent. I would not tell the hospital that the project is proven to reduce falls. Next I would repeat the audit with randomly chosen records checked by someone else, follow falls and harm over a longer period, and compare our practice with NICE falls guidance. Meanwhile every patient still needs an individual falls plan.
What this station tests
- An audit checks practice against a standard; it does not prove an intervention works.
- Convert falls to a rate per 1,000 occupied bed days so periods of different length and occupancy can be compared.
- Small numbers of events make rates unstable: a change from 13 to 10 falls may be chance.
- The people who run a project should not be the only ones auditing it; choose records at random.
- Recommend proportionately: continue what is safe, and gather better evidence before wider change.
Sources for the clinical content
- NICE: Falls: assessment and prevention in older people and in people 50 and over at higher risk (NG249)
- NHS England: Clinical audit
- NMC: The Code
An original practice scenario with invented patients. Not an exam question. Written from the guidance above and reviewed before release: how we write and check stations.