Mental health nursing: A colleague punishes a patient
NMC OSCE practice station
Professional values · 1 min to read · 10 min to perform
A written station. Free to try, no sign-up.
The task
You are a registered nurse on an acute mental health ward. At 21:30 you overhear a healthcare assistant tell a patient, Mrs Gwen Ashby, that she will not get her phone back or be allowed in the garden tomorrow because she shouted at staff earlier. Mrs Ashby is informal and has not been told that any restriction is part of her care plan. The assistant is experienced and popular with the team. In the response sheet, write what you would do now, explain why, and say what you would do afterwards.
Studying with someone? Practise this station with a friend, free →
Answer for this station
What a strong answer does
- Safety: Acts straight away to protect Mrs Ashby's dignity and rights: reassures her and corrects the false information that she has been banned.
- Safety: Recognises that a punishment unrelated to the care plan is not acceptable, whatever the seniority or popularity of the colleague.
- Speaks privately to the colleague, calmly and factually, about the standard expected.
- Escalates to the nurse in charge that night and uses the incident system and the raising concerns route.
- Gives clear reasoning referring to rights, therapeutic relationship and the Code.
- Documents accurately, factually and with times.
- Plans follow-up: care plan review of any restriction, debrief with Mrs Ashby, support and training for the colleague, and reflection.
Model answer
I would go straight to Mrs Ashby. She is an informal patient, and I would speak to her calmly, check how she is and explain that she has not been banned from her phone or the garden as punishment. I would arrange for her to have her phone if it is hers and there is no assessed and documented risk. I would listen to her account of the earlier shouting and offer a conversation later. I would then speak privately to the healthcare assistant, calmly and factually, and explain that restrictions on patients must be based on assessed risk, recorded in the care plan with a reason and a review date, and must never be used to punish. I would not argue in front of patients. His experience and popularity do not change this. I would tell the nurse in charge tonight and I would complete an incident report as the policy requires, describing what I heard, the time and who was present, with no opinions. If the matter was not taken seriously I would use the raising concerns route to the ward manager, the safeguarding lead or the freedom to speak up guardian. The Code requires me to prioritise people, treat them with dignity and act on concerns about colleagues, and the Mental Health Act Code of Practice says restrictions must never be used to punish, only as a proportionate response to an individually identified risk. Afterwards I would ask for the care plans to be checked so that any restrictions are individual and reviewed. I would offer the healthcare assistant support and feedback and make sure Mrs Ashby has a chance to talk. I would reflect on my own practice and record my actions, signed and timed.
What this station tests
- Punishing a patient is never acceptable, and informal patients keep their rights.
- Restrictions must be individual, based on assessed risk, written in the care plan and reviewed.
- A registered nurse is accountable for raising concerns, even about popular or senior colleagues.
- Protect the patient first, then address the colleague, then escalate and record.
- Use the incident and raising concerns routes.
Sources for the clinical content
An original practice scenario with invented patients. Not an exam question. Written from the guidance above and reviewed before release: how we write and check stations.