Parent unsure about the HPV vaccine
NAC OSCE practice station
Counselling & explanation · 2 min to read · 11 min to perform
Discuss her concerns and give her the information she needs to decide.
Free · no sign-up · uses your one free station
Open the full station (charts, voice, result letter) →The task
You are a family physician in a community clinic. Hélène Bouchard, aged 41, has come without her daughter Zoe, aged 12, who is due to receive school-based vaccines this term. Mrs Bouchard has questions about the HPV vaccine. Discuss her concerns and give her the information she needs to decide. The examiner will not take part in the conversation.
Studying with someone? Practise this station with a friend, free →
Answer for this station
What a strong answer does
- Introduces themselves, confirms identity and asks open questions about her concerns before giving information.
- Explores her reasons: fertility, safety, age and sexual activity, and her own history with HPV.
- Explains clearly what the vaccine prevents: infection with the HPV types that cause most cervical cancers and several other cancers and genital warts.
- Corrects the fertility myth and the sexual-activity concern with evidence: no effect on fertility, and vaccination does not lead to earlier sexual activity.
- Explains vaccination before exposure works best, which is why it is offered at this age.
- Safety: Gives accurate safety information: mild arm soreness, fainting after any needle (sit for 15 minutes), and very rarely severe allergic reactions; vaccine safety is monitored in Canada.
- States that the national recommendation is one dose for healthy people aged 9 to 20, and that provincial schedules differ so she should confirm what her province offers.
- Supports an informed decision, offers to answer Zoe's own questions and suggests ways to manage her needle fear.
- Offers written information and says she can still change her mind later, noting Pap/cervical screening is still needed in adulthood.
Model answer
I introduce myself, confirm Mrs Bouchard's name and date of birth and ask her to tell me what she has read and what worries her. I learn that she fears an effect on fertility and early sexual activity, that she thinks Zoe is too young, that she had a treated abnormal Pap test herself and that Zoe is needle-phobic with one faint. I do not lecture; I reflect her concerns and ask permission to share information. I explain that HPV is a very common virus that causes almost all cervical cancers and some cancers of the throat, anus, vulva, vagina and penis, and genital warts, and that vaccination works best before exposure, which is why it is offered at this age. I correct the myths: studies show no effect on fertility and no increase in sexual activity after vaccination. I give honest safety information: a sore, red or swollen arm and headache are common, fainting can follow any injection so Zoe should sit for 15 minutes afterward, and severe allergic reactions are rare, with vaccine safety monitored in Canada. I explain that the National Advisory Committee on Immunization recommends one dose for healthy people aged 9 to 20, that provincial schedules differ, and that she should check with the school program. I respect her decision, offer to speak with Zoe, discuss managing needle fear, mention that cervical screening is still needed in adulthood, give written information from a Canadian source, and tell her she can change her mind later.
What this station tests
- Ask about concerns before giving facts, and avoid lecturing.
- Correct fertility and sexual activity myths with evidence in plain words.
- Be honest about common side effects, fainting and rare allergic reactions.
- Know the national recommendation, and say that provincial programs may differ.
- Support an informed decision and respect the parent's autonomy.
Sources for the clinical content
- Canadian Immunization Guide: HPV vaccine
- NACI statement of July 24, 2024: updated recommendations on HPV vaccines (summary)
- Immunize Canada: HPV vaccine school programs by province
An original practice scenario with invented patients. Not an exam question. Written from the guidance above and reviewed before release: how we write and check stations.