Knee injury playing soccer
NAC OSCE practice station
Examination · 2 min to read · 11 min to perform
Perform an examination of her right knee.
Free · no sign-up · uses your one free station
Open the full station (charts, voice, result letter) →The task
You are a family physician in a walk-in clinic. Chloe Fraser, aged 22, twisted her right knee playing soccer three days ago. She is sitting on the couch with both legs exposed. Perform an examination of her right knee. Say aloud what you are doing at each step. The examiner will report the findings when you say what you are doing. At the end, summarize your findings, say what you think is going on and what you would do next.
Studying with someone? Practise this station with a friend, free →
Answer for this station
What a strong answer does
- Introduces themselves, checks identity, explains and gains consent, and asks about pain before examining.
- Takes a focused history of the mechanism, popping, swelling within hours, locking and giving way.
- Inspects both knees for swelling, bruising and alignment, and tests for an effusion.
- Palpates joint lines and bony landmarks, and assesses range of motion.
- Applies the Ottawa knee rule: reasons that the inability to flex to 90 degrees means an X-ray is needed.
- Performs ligament tests (Lachman, anterior drawer, posterior drawer, collaterals) correctly.
- Assesses menisci and distal neurovascular status.
- Summarizes findings and gives anterior cruciate ligament tear with possible meniscal injury as the likely diagnosis.
- Safety: Plans management: X-ray, early physiotherapy, crutches and analgesia, MRI and orthopedic or sports medicine referral, and no return to sport yet.
- Explains rehabilitation and surgery options honestly and gives red flags such as a cold or numb foot, calf swelling or fever.
Model answer
I introduce myself, confirm Ms Fraser's name and date of birth, explain the examination and gain consent. I take a brief history of mechanism: a planted foot and twist with a pop, swelling within an hour and giving way. I expose both legs and inspect for swelling, bruising and alignment, and I test for an effusion, which is moderate. I palpate the joint lines and bony landmarks, noting lateral joint line tenderness only. I assess range of motion, finding flexion to 85 degrees with full extension, and ask her to take four steps, which she manages with a limp. Because she cannot flex to 90 degrees, the Ottawa knee rule supports an X-ray. I test the ligaments: Lachman and anterior drawer are positive with a soft end point, posterior drawer and collaterals are stable. McMurray is equivocal because of pain. I check the pulses and sensation distally. I summarize: a young athlete with a twisting injury, immediate swelling, a pop and instability, a positive Lachman and anterior drawer, suggesting an anterior cruciate ligament tear, with possible lateral meniscal involvement. The X-ray shows no fracture. I explain this plainly, arrange crutches, analgesia, early physiotherapy, an MRI and referral to orthopedics or sports medicine, and advise no return to soccer until reviewed. I discuss that treatment choices range from rehabilitation to reconstruction depending on her goals, and I give red flags such as a cold, numb or pale foot, calf swelling or fever, which need urgent care or a call to 911.
What this station tests
- Rapid swelling, a pop and instability after a twisting injury suggest an ACL tear.
- Lachman is more sensitive than the anterior drawer test.
- The Ottawa knee rule guides X-ray use; inability to flex to 90 degrees is a criterion.
- Check the neurovascular status of the limb in every injury.
- Give realistic information about rehabilitation and surgery without promising a return date.
Sources for the clinical content
- Ottawa Hospital Research Institute: Ottawa Knee Rule
- Stiell et al., JAMA 1997: implementation of the Ottawa Knee Rule
An original practice scenario with invented patients. Not an exam question. Written from the guidance above and reviewed before release: how we write and check stations.