A son asks you not to tell his father the scan result
RCSI OSCE practice station

Ethics, consent & capacity · 1 min to read · 10 min to perform

Try a real conversation · RCSI OSCEAI practice

Michael Healy, aged 81, had a scan yesterday that showed an abnormality in his lung.

Michael HealyNurse, what did that scan show? Nobody will give me a straight answer.

Free · no sign-up · uses your one free station

The task

You are the nurse on a medical ward in Ireland. Michael Healy, aged 81, had a scan yesterday that showed an abnormality in his lung. The doctor has spoken with his son, Colm, but not yet with Mr Healy. Colm has asked staff not to tell his father. Mr Healy has just asked you what the scan showed. Both are at the bedside. Introduce yourself and respond to both of them. Decide what you can say and what you must do. Record your actions in the note provided.

Answer for this station

What a strong answer does

  • Introduces self to both and acknowledges the difficult moment without taking sides.
  • Presumes capacity and checks Mr Healy's understanding, orientation and what he wants to know.
  • Safety: Recognises that an adult with capacity has the right to information and that his son cannot decide for him.
  • Safety: Does not lie, deflect or give the result personally when the doctor has not disclosed it, and says what can be done.
  • Explores Mr Healy's reasons and experience and checks who he wants present.
  • Listens to Colm's fears, acknowledges them and offers support for him separately.
  • Arranges for the consultant to meet them promptly and informs the nurse in charge.
  • Offers sources of support such as the cancer nurse specialist, pastoral care and the Irish Cancer Society.
  • Documents the conversation, the patient's wishes, the son's request and the plan, including a note on capacity.

Model answer

I introduce myself to Mr Healy and Colm and acknowledge that this is a difficult moment. I ask Mr Healy what he understands about why he had the scan and how much he wants to know. He is fully orientated, explains that he suspects a growth, and says he wants everything told plainly with Colm beside him. I presume he has capacity, as the Assisted Decision-Making Act requires, and nothing I see suggests otherwise. I ask Colm what he fears. He is afraid his father will give up, particularly after the death of his mother. I acknowledge this and explain gently that it is Mr Healy's right to know what is happening to him and that Colm cannot decide that for him. I tell both that the doctor will give the result because the doctor has the full picture and can answer questions. I explain that I will not lie to Mr Healy or tell him something untrue, and that I will not hide that he has asked. I telephone the consultant's team, explain that Mr Healy has asked and has the capacity to be told, and ask for a meeting tomorrow with his son present and a nurse. I also raise that the result was shared with his son before Mr Healy had agreed to this. I inform the nurse in charge. I offer the support of the cancer nurse specialist and pastoral care, and offer Colm time to talk to someone separately. I record the conversation, Mr Healy's wishes, Colm's request, my assessment of his understanding, who was informed and the plan.

What this station tests

  • Presume an adult has capacity. Family cannot override the right to information of a patient who has capacity.
  • Do not lie or deflect. Be honest that the doctor will give the result and make that happen quickly.
  • Ask the patient how much he wants to know and who he wants present.
  • Listen to the relative's fears. They often come from love and past loss.
  • Document the patient's wishes, the family's request and the steps taken.

Sources for the clinical content

An original practice scenario with invented patients. Not an exam question. Written from the guidance above and reviewed before release: how we write and check stations.

Practise next

About the RCSI OSCE →