A visitor at the desk asks about a client
IENCAP OSCE practice station

Ethics, consent & capacity · 2 min to read · 13 min to perform

Try a real conversation · IENCAP OSCEAI practice

A woman at the desk says she is the neighbour of a client, Kamal Aziz, and asks how he is, what is wrong, when he is going home and whether she should feed his dog.

Marlene ChoI'm Kamal's neighbour. What's wrong with him? Is he going to be okay? How long is he in for?

Free · no sign-up · uses your one free station

The task

You are the nurse on a medical unit in Ontario. A woman at the desk says she is the neighbour of a client, Kamal Aziz, and asks how he is, what is wrong, when he is going home and whether she should feed his dog. Mr Aziz is awake in his room, alert, and able to make his own decisions. Speak with the visitor, then with Mr Aziz. Decide what you can and cannot share, and what you should do. Record what you did in the note provided.

Answer for this station

What a strong answer does

  • Safety: Introduces self courteously to the visitor and does not disclose any health information before checking with the client.
  • Explains the reason for confidentiality in a friendly, non-defensive way and acknowledges her concern.
  • Safety: Does not disclose diagnosis, prognosis or discharge information, even when pressed.
  • Safety: Speaks with Mr Aziz privately and asks what he is willing to share and with whom.
  • Records his privacy preferences and tells staff, including who may be told he is in hospital.
  • Offers to pass on his message and helps him arrange pet care, using the social worker if needed.
  • Follows the CNO privacy standard and PHIPA principles: collect, use and share only with consent or lawful authority.
  • Returns to the visitor and shares only what the client agreed, kindly and consistently.
  • Documents the exchange factually.

Model answer

I go to the desk, introduce myself to Ms Cho and explain kindly that I cannot share any information about a client without his permission, but that I will go and ask him. I stay pleasant when she presses me and I do not give her any diagnosis, prognosis or discharge information. I acknowledge that she cares about Mr Aziz and the dog. I go to Mr Aziz's room and speak with him privately. I ask whether he knows Ms Cho and what he would like me to tell her. He says she has a key to his home but that he does not want her to know what is wrong with him. He is willing for her to know he is in hospital, and asks that she feed and walk his dog, Biscuit. He does not want his landlord or his employer told anything. I check his observations, which are stable, and see that no privacy preferences are recorded. I write his preferences in the chart and tell the nurses on the unit. Under the Personal Health Information Protection Act and the CNO privacy standard, I need his consent to share anything beyond what is allowed by the hospital directory, and he has limited it. I return to Ms Cho and tell her only what he agreed: that he is here, that he has asked her to feed and walk Biscuit, and that he will thank her. I also tell her that I cannot say any more. I offer to contact the social worker about pet care for Mr Aziz and document the exchange.

What this station tests

  • Do not disclose a client's health information to a visitor without consent, even a friendly or persistent neighbour.
  • Ask the client what he is happy to share and with whom, and record it.
  • Pass on messages. Confidentiality does not mean being unhelpful.
  • Confirming that a client is in hospital depends on the client's wishes under privacy law and hospital policy.
  • Be courteous and consistent so the visitor is not left feeling accused.

Sources for the clinical content

An original practice scenario with invented patients. Not an exam question. Written from the guidance above and reviewed before release: how we write and check stations.

Practise next

About the IENCAP OSCE →