Overdose in a woman medically cleared in ED
MRCPsych CASC practice station
Mental health · 1 min to read · 7 min to perform
Take a history that focuses on the circumstances of the overdose, and assess her risk of further self-harm and suicide.
Free · no sign-up · uses your one free station
Open the full station (charts, voice, result letter) →The task
You are a core trainee in psychiatry in the emergency department of a general hospital. Ms Joanne Walsh, aged 38, was brought in last night after taking an overdose of tablets. The medical team have now said she is medically fit for assessment. She is alone in a side room. Take a history that focuses on the circumstances of the overdose, and assess her risk of further self-harm and suicide. There is no need to discuss management in detail. The examiner will not take part in the conversation.
Studying with someone? Practise this station with a friend, free →
Answer for this station
What a strong answer does
- Introduces self, checks her identity, asks about her wellbeing and invites her to describe in her own words what happened before asking closed questions.
- Identifies the precipitant and builds a timeline of events leading to the overdose, including what was taken, how much and with what.
- Explores planning and suicidal intent at the time: saved tablets, timing to avoid discovery, a note or message, final acts and how help was reached.
- Safety: Asks directly about her feelings now toward having survived, and about current suicidal thoughts, plans and intent to act again.
- Safety: Asks about access to means at home and who she lives with or who could support her tonight.
- Explores low mood and biological symptoms of depression, including sleep, appetite, weight, energy, hopelessness and guilt.
- Takes a history of alcohol and drug use, and previous self-harm, past attempts and psychiatric treatment.
- Asks about physical health, medication, the medical team's findings and her own views and worries, including her fear of being detained or losing her job.
- Explores protective factors and the social context: family, friends, pet, work, finances, housing, and the relationship loss.
- Notices and responds to emotional cues, such as her fear of being sectioned and her ambivalence about survival, with empathy rather than moving straight on.
- Uses open then focused questions in plain language, avoids jargon and leading questions, and does not rely on a checklist or scale.
- Keeps a clear structure and covers the history within the time, with a brief summary back to her at the end that does not label her risk from a score.
Model answer
I introduce myself, check Ms Walsh's name and date of birth and ask how she is after a hard night. I acknowledge that talking about this is difficult, explain that I want to understand what happened and that I will be asking some direct questions. I invite her to tell me in her own words what led up to the overdose, and I let her pause. I follow the story with open then focused questions. I establish the precipitant, which was her partner leaving on Sunday, with pressure at work and money in the background. I ask exactly what she took, how many tablets, whether she drank alcohol, and when. I explore planning: she had saved tablets for two weeks, waited until her sister was at work, sent a goodbye text and tidied the flat. I ask how help was reached and what she feels about that. I notice her ambivalence, relief about her sister, but a wish not to be here, and I ask directly about suicidal thoughts now, whether she has a plan and whether she might act again if she went home. I ask about more tablets at home and who lives with her. I ask about mood and biological symptoms, including early waking, weight loss and hopelessness, and I ask about alcohol, drugs, previous self-harm, past psychiatric treatment and family history. I ask about her physical health and what the medical team said. I explore protective factors, including her sister and her cat, and her social situation, including debt and work. When she voices her fear of being sectioned or losing her job I stop and respond with empathy, explore what worries her and do not reassure falsely. I summarise back and check that I have understood. I describe her risk factors and needs in words, not by calling her low or high risk from a tool. I tell her I will discuss the findings with my senior and the crisis team, and that I will not be leaving her alone with those thoughts.
What this station tests
- Ask separately about the circumstances of the overdose (planning, timing, precautions against discovery, final acts) and about intent now; both matter.
- Ask directly about current suicidal thoughts, plans and access to means. Unasked questions in this area are a safety failure.
- Use the person's own words and notice cues; fear of detention or job loss can make people guarded.
- NICE advises against using risk assessment tools or scales to predict suicide or to decide who gets treatment. Assess needs and risk factors and describe them in words.
- Cover protective factors and social context, not only risk, and finish with a short summary checked back with the patient.
Sources for the clinical content
- NICE NG225: Self-harm: assessment, management and preventing recurrence
- NICE NG222: Depression in adults: treatment and management
- Royal College of Psychiatrists: CASC syllabus and blueprint (March 2023)
An original practice scenario with invented patients. Not an exam question. Written from the guidance above and reviewed before release: how we write and check stations.